Oh my! We have carbon copies with the retrieve! Thane will even point his nose/ nudge to exactly where he dropped the item on the floor if I say Where? or I Can't Find it. LOL Yup it does me a ton of good on the floor! If Thane had not had such a sensitive tummy for so long which I am beginning to feel was more the Merrick food than the giardia, I would try smothering something nummy. I have this really neat plastic avian target stick that came with Clicker Training for Birds. I am going to try it next as its about the diameter of one of those disposable bic pens. Its hard plastic and thus easily washable. I just have to think carefully about any food involvement here as the last thing I want is to spiral his gut back out of control. If I was in your position though Rox'E, I'd probably try adding a tad of tasty food. As for the household manners, have you tried tethering when she is not working specifically with you or training with you. I did that from the start with Thane and it worked superbly. Of course I don't have a household of multiple dogs and it was hard to do some things. I have the advantage that I could tether to the chair but perhaps a hands free lead? I'm just asking- it might not be something feasible. In some situation, its possible that the only attention she really got was bad attention. It is hard to lose that pattern of behavior if it helped you survive. If she was found as a stray, scavenging probably kept her alive also. Karyn and Thane