I wrote: "Meaning" is a nonsense word. You wrote: Exactly! It may turn out that meanings are natural kinds associated with sophisticated nervous systems! I write: Can you elaborate? You wrote: So, one can't necessarily tie "meaning" to transcendental idealism as if such idealism were a definitional given. I write: Ah, I have sort of fallen out of discussing 'philosophical archetypes'. No need to to explain, but a decent context might help. You wrote: So how many Wittgensteinians does it take to convert a nonWittgensteinian to Catholicism? It takes just one but don't tell her. There's a joke somewhere in that but don't bother wasting time on it. I write: No need to elaborate here; I did chuckle, albeit Catholicism would not be my choice word. (W says plenty on religion) -- He lived a wonderful life. ========================================== Need Something? Check here: http://ludwig.squarespace.com/wittrslinks/