Dear Paul, I don't think Neville would object too much about developing an 'evolution' thread. It is mentioned on his website. When Dawkins was asked the 'hot potato' question of how you get from inorganic chemicals to life (Abiogenesis) he conveniently sidesteps it by claiming that the answer to this must come from another scientific discipline - passing the buck to someone else. If this question cannot be answered by anyone, and it hasn't yet, what is he building his evolutionary faith on? You ought to listen to the Oxford Union debate and you will understand what I'm getting at. Jack