David, Good point! When I first moved to high power I couldn't figure out how to retain the motor any other way than an Aerotech retainer. They're on all of my high power rockets and the only thing I use. I've heard of folks using tape between the motor and the motor tube (old school) but every time I try that on a model rocket I eject the motor so I've not tried it on a high power rocket. The retainer is just a required part of the rocket that isn't usually provide - same as chutes, chute protectors, and shock cords. Thanks, Mike On Tue, Oct 16, 2012 at 4:19 PM, David Erbas-White <derbas@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote: > On 10/16/2012 3:44 PM, rtd@xxxxxxxxxxxx wrote: > > I wouldn't necessarily disagree with the choice of an Initiator (heck, I > just bought another one from Jack on Saturday!), but if he'd like to get a > slightly higher flier in the Aerotech lineup, I'd recommend the Mustang. > Pros/cons: Initiator is a bit bigger/wider, thus gives a more impressive > display on lift-off, and less chance of losing it to the wind due to lower > altitude, but the larger fins are more easily 'bent' over time. If one > starts to get 'altitude fever', the Mustang is a bit of a higher altitude > rocket, but still (mostly) easily recoverable. > > For ANY of the Aerotech kits, I always recommend moving up one parachute > size due to the hardness of the lakebed. Further, at the step where you're > supposed to glue the thrust washer/thrust ring together, CA never seems to > work right -- either use epoxy or yellow wood glue. I also recommend epoxy > for the launch lugs. Finally, if using a reloadable motor, ALWAYS use one or > two layers of masking tape around the engine hook and engine. The Aerotech > engine hook (at least for me) seems to have about a 50% chance of kicking > the engine at ejection, no matter what type of engine I use, unless I've > taped it. > > As an alternative (and agreeing with Michael Klett), I would highly > recommend the Polecat Goblin. However, IMHO, one should always use positive > motor retention in the Polecat kits, which for me generally means purchase > of an Aeropack retainer -- a bit pricey for someone's first rocket. That > being said, the Goblin would be great for someone starting with mid-power, > as it's easily used as a Level 1 rocket. > > David Erbas-White > > > >> >> When I talked to Chris on the phone earlier today, he mentioned that he >> was contemplating the purchase of an Aerotech Initiator kit as his first >> foray into mid-power. I let him know that it's a great little flyer, and >> hard to go wrong with, but I suspect that just about everyone here probably >> has a favorite "getting your feet wet" rocket kit to suggest, and I'm >> curious to see what everyone suggests. >> > > > -- > ROC-Chat mailing list > roc-chat@xxxxxxxxxxxxx > //www.freelists.org/list/roc-chat > -- ROC-Chat mailing list roc-chat@xxxxxxxxxxxxx //www.freelists.org/list/roc-chat