Out of curiosity, with nightly FULL rman backups of a production database, why would you recommend a value greater than 7 for keep time? I had a hard time imagining a scenario where you'd have to go back 21 days for a production recovery - I'm wondering if I'm missing some technical aspect here... Thanks, Chris On Tue, Dec 10, 2013 at 9:03 AM, Tim Gorman <tim@xxxxxxxxx> wrote: > Coming late to the discussion, not sure if anyone else has made this > point... > > Having an RMAN repository (a.k.a. recovery catalog, etc) is belt and > suspenders (or belt and braces for many). There is always a "recovery > catalog" in the target database's control files, so you've always got a > belt to prevent your trousers from falling. If you don't set > CONTROL_FILE_RECORD_KEEP_TIME to at least 21, then it's more cheap string > than a belt, but it's a belt. > > A recovery catalog is a replicated copy of the recovery catalog with more > history, thus suspenders/braces in addition to the belt. > > It is not technical merit, but rather personal/corporate choice, that > determines whether one wears one or both. > >