[Wittrs] Re: What the Man in the Room Knows (and when does he know it?)

From: "iro3isdx" <xznwrjnk-evca@xxxxxxxxx>
To: wittrsamr@xxxxxxxxxxxxx
Date: Wed, 24 Mar 2010 14:27:15 -0000

--- In Wittrs@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx, Gordon Swobe <wittrsamr@...> wrote:


> How do you respond to his answer to the systems reply?

So Searle is being asked questions in Chinese, giving answers  in
Chinese, and doing it so well that you cannot tell from  the
questions/answers that he is not Chinese.

Searle asserts that he does that without any understanding  of Chinese.

I call it bullshit.

Regards,
Neil

=========================================
Need Something? Check here: http://ludwig.squarespace.com/wittrslinks/

Follow-Ups:
- [Wittrs] Re: What the Man in the Room Knows (and when does he know it?)
  - From: gabuddabout

References:
- [Wittrs] Re: What the Man in the Room Knows (and when does he know it?)
  - From: Gordon Swobe

Other related posts:

» [Wittrs] What the Man in the Room Knows (and when does he know it?)- SWM
» [Wittrs] Re: What the Man in the Room Knows (and when does he know it?)- Gordon Swobe
» [Wittrs] Re: What the Man in the Room Knows (and when does he know it?)- SWM
» [Wittrs] Re: What the Man in the Room Knows (and when does he know it?)- Gordon Swobe
» [Wittrs] Re: What the Man in the Room Knows (and when does he know it?)- SWM
» [Wittrs] Re: What the Man in the Room Knows (and when does he know it?)- Gordon Swobe
» [Wittrs] Re: What the Man in the Room Knows (and when does he know it?)- SWM
» [Wittrs] Re: What the Man in the Room Knows (and when does he know it?)- iro3isdx
» [Wittrs] Re: What the Man in the Room Knows (and when does he know it?)- Gordon Swobe
» [Wittrs] Re: What the Man in the Room Knows (and when does he know it?)- Gordon Swobe
» [Wittrs] Re: What the Man in the Room Knows (and when does he know it?) - iro3isdx
» [Wittrs] Re: What the Man in the Room Knows (and when does he know it?)- gabuddabout
» [Wittrs] Re: What the Man in the Room Knows (and when does he know it?)- iro3isdx
» [Wittrs] Re: What the Man in the Room Knows (and when does he know it?)- gabuddabout
» [Wittrs] Re: What the Man in the Room Knows (and when does he know it?)- iro3isdx
» [Wittrs] Re: What the Man in the Room Knows (and when does he know it?)- Gordon Swobe
» [Wittrs] Re: What the Man in the Room Knows (and when does he know it?)- iro3isdx
» [Wittrs] Re: What the Man in the Room Knows (and when does he know it?)- Gordon Swobe
» [Wittrs] Re: What the Man in the Room Knows (and when does he know it?)- iro3isdx