First off, the only thing that's technically illegal is sending Spam, and only by the billions. There is no law for "slandering" a person's email address (or slandering a company by posing as the company that is sending them) which is the subject of this thread. But to continue on with Spam since you brought it up.....being technically "illegal", then finding the authorities that actually have a backbone and will actually DO SOMETHING about it, are two totally different things. Finding hits in a search engine for a search phrase, and finding the precedents where something was actually DONE, are two totally different things. To date, there has been only ONE person prosecuted under the anti-spam law, and only because he sent countless BILLIONS of UCE's. I personally have filed numerous complaints with my local District Attorney's offices (for both various email and phone harassment), and NOT ONCE did they ever follow up or even call back! I've also filed countless police reports locally AND in the local domicile of the parasite....NOTHING. They simply do not care. Window dressing, eye candy. Here in the USA, there may be laws, but they are not enforced. The Gov't here creates similar laws all the time by the thousands, just to be ignored. And in the unlikely rare event you CAN find someone that actually cares, the scumbag will get some bottom-feeding lawyer that will get them off on a "technicality", so they can continue on with their rein of cyber-terror and cyber-crimes. Or, some spastic judge (as you cited) that's more concerned with the 1st Amendment that people's legit law-abiding businesses and well being. I see it all the time, I've lived it, I know. Sure, there may be "laws", however, Laws are USELESS without the people with the backbone that will ENFORCE them. It's going to take (someone like me?) to get several thousand people to march on Capitol Hill in D.C. that will create enough of a media frenzy, to get the Gov't to actually TAKE some action against these parasites, or a class-action lawsuit against the Gov't for failure to enforce. Why do you think they still do it? Still spam? Still commit the internet fraud? Still spoof/slander businesses and people's email addresses? Simply because, they CAN. Drastic times, desperate measures. Fight back the only way we know how. I, and others that have also experienced these atrocities first hand, will consider the Gov't as "caring" when they actually start prosecuting and delivering JAIL TIME for these pieces of excrement. -Clint God Bless Clint Hamilton, Owner http://www.OrpheusComputing.com http://www.ComputersCustomBuilt.com ----- Original Message ----- From: "David Grossman" It is illegal, Clint. Google gives "about" 1,030,000 hits at http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=anti-spam+laws&aq=2&oq=anti-spam+ for "anti-spam laws." That shows that the government does care. Some of these laws are detailed at http://www.spamlaws.com/spam-laws.html Unfortunately, there are still problems. We're not out of the woods yet. The Washington Post recently reported, at http://voices.washingtonpost.com/securityfix/2008/09/virginia_anti-spam_law_ overtur.html , that "The Virginia Supreme Court today struck down a state anti-spam law, saying the statute violated the First Amendment right to free and anonymous speech. The decision also tossed out the conviction of a North Carolina man once described as one of the most prolific spammers." That Virginia case proved that anti-spam legislation is still not perfect. However, it is in place, and it is improving all the time. It's important to press the legislators to put through even stricter laws. Furthermore, althought the Virginia law was struck down, it does not mean that the government does not care. To the contrary - the government did create the law. That means that they do care. Now they will have to re-write the existing law so that it will be constitutional, and they will have to pass the new law. David Grossman > -----Original Message----- > > It's NOT illegal, THAT is the problem. The Gov't here > doesn't > care, nor does any other country. Fight fire with fire. I > speak from much experience.....unfortunately. > -Clint > > > ----- Original Message ----- > From: "David Grossman" > > > Two reasons why I don't think that will work, Clint: > > 1. By sending them spam and trial subscriptions, we are > lowering ourselves > to their level, and thereby lowering our own self-esteem and > self-worth. We > may or may not stop them, but the price may be too high for > decent people > like us to bear. > > 2. If what they are doing is illegal, then when we do the > same > thing it > would also be illegal. The difference is that they know how > to > carry out > their nefarious activities without getting caught, and we > don't > know the > tricks of their trade. They won't get caught. We will get > caught. It's not > worth it. > > David Grossman > > > > > -----Original Message----- > > > > > In short Dale, there's nothing you can really do because > > it's > > likely this kind of cyber-terrorist scum is sending these > > attacks from one of those cyber-terrorist criminal internet > > cafes out of the USA, or using a email header forging > > program. > > All you can TRY to do: is you MUST get the full email > > headers > > in order to report it, but that's likely to be futile due > > to > > what I said above, and in the unlikely event they ARE from > > a > > REAL PC; it's from Europe (RIPE), Asia (APNIC) or S. > > America > > (LACNIC) the ISP's there don't care because they're in on > > this > > type of state-sponsored cyber-terrorism. > > > > You MIGHT, POSSIBLY, be able to do something if the email > > headers are not forged, and are based in the USA. But you > > have > > no way of knowing if the headers are real or fake. If the > > originating IP shows it's based in the USA, it's slightly > > more > > likely they MIGHT be real, but still not very likely. > > > > As Phil mentioned, contrary to all ISP's TOS/TOA policies, > > they > > DO CONDONE this kind of behavior, ignore it and turn a > > blind > > eye to it. And, SpamCop IS IN ON IT. For over a decade > > I've > > been telling those idiots at SpamCop the addresses to which > > they are "allegedly reporting" these kinds of atrocities > > are > > BOGUS--either no longer valid or NEVER WERE in use! I have > > even PROVIDED THEM with the real addresses! They don't > > care, > > they just keep using the same bogus reporting email > > addresses > > making the unsuspecting SC user think that something is > > actually being done. > > > > What you have to do is take matters into your own hands, > > but > > again that could only help IF the email headers are real > > and > > not forged, and several other things have to fall into > > place > > for you: For example, if the emails have a website's URL > > in > > it, and IF, IF, IF, the whois information on the domain is > > NOT > > bogus (they usually are bogus, something also that is "not > > allowed" by registrar's TOS/TOA yet they condone it), you > > can > > find ways of attacking the domain owner. Subscribe their > > email > > address to every kind of BS you can find, and have all > > sorts > > of > > ridiculous things sent to their street address. For their > > name, use something additional like "cyber-terrorist > > parasite", > > then when they get all these emails sent to them, trial > > magazine subscriptions, vacuum cleaner free trials, etc., > > etc., > > it will be addressed to "Cyber-terrorist parasite", and > > they'll > > also have to handle the return of all these products and > > cancellation of magazine subscriptions. Be sure and pick > > some > > "really choice" magazines and products. Magazines like > > "Ge*nital Acne Quarterly", "Closet Cross-Dresser", etc., > > they'll have to cancel (or will they?? HA!! No they don't > > exist....at least not to my knowledge, but you get my > > point), > > LOL. Products like "personal pleasure enhancement > > products" > > that have "send no money now, we'll bill you later" promos, > > preferably from places like "Nadine's House of Pleasure" > > that > > have really descriptive shipping boxes. ROTFLMAO. > > Hopefully > > they'll have really nosy gossipy neighbors and a nosy > > gossiping > > mailman/delivery person that will also make their life a > > hell. > > > > You also immediately tell your ISP about this in efforts to > > thwart any complaints about against you. That's in the > > unlikely event your ISP actually does anything about > > spammers > > and cyber-terrorism. > > -Clint > ========================= The list's FAQ's can be seen by sending an email to PCWorks-request@xxxxxxxxxxxxx with FAQ in the subject line. To unsubscribe, subscribe, set Digest or Vacation to on or off, go to //www.freelists.org/list/pcworks . You can also send an email to PCWorks-request@xxxxxxxxxxxxx with Unsubscribe in the subject line. Your member list settings can be found at //www.freelists.org/cgi-bin/lsg2.cgi/l=pcworks . Once logged in, you have access to numerous other email options. The list archives are located at //www.freelists.org/archives/pcworks/ . All email posted to the list will be placed there in the event anyone needs to look for previous posts. -zxdjhu-