Dave, There are other savings too: 1. You don't need a pic programmer. 2. The other 1-of-n decoders go low when selected, so you need additional circuitry there. 3. In a future narrow band design. The same 10 lines out of the 4017 can switch 10 banpass filters as well! That would mean a 2M to 160 M, multiband unit! - f Sent from BlackBerry® on Airtel -----Original Message----- From: Dave <dave@xxxxxxxxxx> Sender: minima-bounce@xxxxxxxxxxxxx Date: Sun, 09 Feb 2014 14:58:54 To: <minima@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> Reply-To: minima@xxxxxxxxxxxxx Subject: [minima] Re: band switching Steve: Of course if you use a I2C expander such as the PCF8574, you use 0 additional I/O lines. It connects to the I2C in parallel with the Si570. Dave - WB6DHW <http://wb6dhw.com> On 2/9/2014 2:43 PM, Steve VK2SJA wrote: > >> Steve, this uses just two lines. > Alright. I'll admit it. This muddle headed wombat is still very confused. > > 1 x Pin to pulse counter in 4017 decade counter to select band pass filter > +1 x Pin to reset 4017 decade counter to default known start state > > = 2 pins > > 2 pins + 1 pin for controlling the low pass filter selection = 3 pins. > > vs > > 3 pins Binary Coded Decimal (BCD) to control *both* low pass filter > selection and the output band pass filter selection. > > Two different ways to arrive at the same level of control. But is it not > still 3 pins = 3 pins? > > So where are we saving an IO line? > > I'm probably being completely daft and missing the flaming obvious but I > just can't see it. > > Help! > > 73, Steve. > > > > > > > > > > >