Yes, in the step 2 process, the Bookshare tools rate the quality of the book and gives it a suggested rating. The validator can override that rating. I validated a book last week with a rank of 99.97 I think it was. You know that was a top quality book and I barely had to do anything to it. I think what people are asking for, is, if this can be done at the step 2 process, why can't it be done at the step 1 process, instead of the submitter choosing a rating. Jamie in Michigan Currently Reading - When Santa Fell to Earth by Cornelia Funke