Thank you, Christy, You do know that I am a very old dog, trying to learn new tricks. I appreciate the wisdom with which tyou answered my questions. Respectfully, Dianne, Hibiscus, and Primrose ----- Original Message ----- From: "Christy Hill" <care4k9@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> To: <vi-clicker-trainers@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> Sent: Saturday, December 13, 2008 12:30 PM Subject: (VICT) Re: questions from a friend about her guide dog >> I have a guide who is now retired but definitely trained >> under older methods who doesn't respond all that accurate to >> clicker training and a current working guide who has been >> trained with the clicker and food reinforcement. > > Any dog can learn to be conditioned. That is what clicker training > is, based > on classical conditioning. The three formulas that have to fit into place > are: > > 1. Timing > 2. Rate of Reinforcement > 3. Criteria > > Any training problem is solved by the formula above. Yes, it does > take a > little longer for a dog to learn that they can be shaped, but I would have > to see how > you are training your dog to see what three above that needs to change. > Many dogs who > are cross over dogs need a lot more reinforcements. Most dog trainers, > even some > clicker trainers are stingy in their reinforcements. I learned this when I > was > fortunate to attend chicken camp with Bob Bailey. I trained a chicken > through an > obstacle course and learned the real meaning of reinforcements and how to > get the > behaviors I want. > > Now criteria is also important. Work on one thing at a time. > Realize that > a cross over dog has to gradually learn how to learn. They need to learn > that it is > ok to do something and explore. You do this by a lot of clicks and > reinforcements > sooner than you would a clicker savvy dog. I had a pup that I grained form > clicker > and a cross over dog, eventually he cross over dog, with time and patience > with me > and learning how to click with chickens, that I got my cross over dog to > shape a lot > nicer than my pup that had been clicked since puppy hood. > > I say this very tongue and cheek, but it was a lesson I had to > learn > myself, it is a trainer's issue, not the subject issue. All subjects can > learn > reinforcements and learn to be conditioned to do a behavior. It is the > trainer that > needs to learn their basics and to reach that dog. Remember, you go in > steps at the > dog's pace, not your pace. Learn your student well and know when to go to > the next > criteria and keep those rapid reinforcements going. > > Christy > > >