Hi Alison,I think we may have had this discussion before, but I for one wouldn't want to be without braille. We are so lucky these days to have all the choice in books which we didn't used to have and it is true that audio is more portable, with an increased possible reading speed for most if not all of us. I've often read an audio book, particularly using synthetic speech, on fast speed and thought afterwards of how much I enjoyed the book, but that it rushed by so quickly and that I didn't spread out the pleasure over a longer period. I always remember having books read to me at school and often having to wait several days for the next exciting instalment. Now we can read when we like and have it all at once if we like. I find that braille enables me to absorb the text more slowly and enjoy the book more thoroughly. Of course, the audio is great for covering a lot of material and so that is good too. Slowing down the reading speed is better for concentration, but I tend to have it fairly fast because I can.
As I've got older I've become rather more fussy about readers and often find aspects of their reading a distraction, partly because I think there are more less good readers about these days and also because I'm more particular these days.
I think that the pluses of synthetic speech are often under-valued by those who won't try it as a means of reading. The main advantage I find is that, once I have got used to the voice, I forget its idiosynchrasies and it always reads in the same way - the text is a stream of information rather than a performance and so the experience is mor like reading for myself than having someone else reading. I still enjoy good readers and there are plenty about of course, but I do increasingly find that my enjoyment of a book is marred by bad or sloppy reading.
We all have our preferences and there are good cases for them all, but my overriding consideration is not having to wait for a book to be made available, which is why I like to scan books and read them as texts. Having the choice of audio or braille is great - as book lovers we have never had it so good.
Best wishes, Voldi At 09:10 27/04/2013, you wrote:
I read very little Braille these days, just the odd magazine and have discontinued my membership of the RNIB Braille Library. I think that maybe as I've got older I have lost some sensitivity in my fingers as I now struggle with older Braille books which have become squashed and maybe I have become lazy too, as it is so much easier and faster to read audio books. Also, as I travel such a lot, it is much more convenient to carry an MP3 player in my handbag, rather than a bulky Braille book. Alison with -----Original Message----- From: ebooktalk-bounce@xxxxxxxxxxxxx [mailto:ebooktalk-bounce@xxxxxxxxxxxxx] On Behalf Of Elaine Harris (Rivendell) Sent: 26 April 2013 22:31 To: ebooktalk@xxxxxxxxxxxxx Subject: [ebooktalk] RNIB Braille library. Alison, No, I borrow Braille from the RNIB library and we have come to an agreement that they send them (still free-post) Airmail, otherwise they take three to four months to get here. We have to pay to return them airmail but still at a heavily discounted rate. I listen to some books and radio drama but only of the highest quality, being a bit too fussy for my own good, perhaps. Also, I suffer (literally) from migraines so being able to read in silence is a boon. I also read aloud to my fully-sighted husband; at the moment we are working our way through an unauthorised biography of Michael Douglas. Chris is a film buff so he knows many if not all of the films discussed. It is a bit "magaziney" in style and, being unauthorised, best to take parts of it with more than a few pinches of salt but it makes us laugh, squirm and groan. (This one is from the Vision Australia library. Details on request since they have an exchange service with libraries across the globe, I understand.) (Oh, and you have visited parts of Australia I have yet to see.) Elaine -----Original Message----- From: ebooktalk-bounce@xxxxxxxxxxxxx [mailto:ebooktalk-bounce@xxxxxxxxxxxxx] On Behalf Of CJ & AA MAY Sent: Saturday, 27 April 2013 2:55 AM To: ebooktalk@xxxxxxxxxxxxx Subject: [ebooktalk] Re: Answering introduction feedback. Elaine, when you say you belong to the RNIB Library, is that th Talking book or Braille Library? I have visited Perth (many times0, Melbourne, Sydney (where I spent 5 days in St. Vincent's Hospital), Cairnes, Kangaroo Island, Adelade and Broom - but still have lots of places we want to visit. We think him crazy, but my brother-in-law is migrating back to the UK next month after 15 years in Aus. Alison -----Original Message----- From: ebooktalk-bounce@xxxxxxxxxxxxx [mailto:ebooktalk-bounce@xxxxxxxxxxxxx] On Behalf Of Elaine Harris (Rivendell) Sent: 26 April 2013 12:50 To: ebooktalk@xxxxxxxxxxxxx Subject: [ebooktalk] Answering introduction feedback. Hello again, Thank you for all the wonderful responses and follow-up potted histories. Clare, I remember you very well and have heard much of you and Voldi both from Sue Sharp and Trish. Alison: I think if I had known how much of "A stranger in a strange land" I would feel, I may not have changed hemispheres. I still hear expressions that are new to me and probably fail abysmally by continuing to use British pronunciations and expressions, for which I make no apology though it has got me into metaphorical hot water more than a few times. We lived in Melbourne when first I came out here; I ran an RPH or Radio for the Print-Handicapped station for a year but left before I went nuts; everyone seemed to have an axe to grind, often on my head! The basic principle with RPH stations is that newspapers, magazines and other publications are read on air, or selections therefrom. Sadly, the quality of reading varies widely and, this country being so huge, the stations are generally only accessible in State capital cities. After RPH, I freelanced for a while, including some television interviewing. Waiting to go on set was tough as the studio floors are concrete and Kati, my first Guide Dog, who emigrated with me, hated being cold and used to cry until the floor-manager had the brilliant idea of providing a rug for her. Then on to Canberra where I worked for a number of years. We are now in more temperate north-west Tasmania, within sight, sound and smell of the ocean. I borrow from the Vision Australia library, one in Auckland as well as the RNIB. We know the postman quite well! Re talk of garden and/or gardening books, last year I read: The Morville Hours: Katherine Swift. History, geography, geology, gardens, horticulture, archaeology, astronomy, linguistics, spirituality. Incredibly inspiring; not an easy read but an educational, revealing, beautiful and lyrical one. A Tour De Force. Based on the principle of the old "Book of Hours" in all its forms, but instead of a monastic day, a garden year. I love the Ellis Peters Cadfael books as much for herb and plant lore as for the mysteries. I have always wanted a walled garden like the one in "The Secret Garden", but my garden here is my therapy, though I am better at weeding and pruning than planting. I first fell in love with descriptive writing with L. M. Montgomery's Anne books, some of which I am re-reading for fun, inspiration and nostalgia. My other vice, apart from being besotted by our dogs, (and enjoying doggy books) is that I now keep a book diary, listing everything I read, reject, or fail to finish. Like most people I used to plough through a book because it seemed the right thing to do; now, if I find myself putting off returning to a book, it is usually an indicator that we're not getting on very well. Happy reading, Elaine