Also, the tone of emails, like texts, are hard to decipher.
Sincerely,
Bill
Pursuing the Effortless...
BigFaceLoveYoga.com
🤙🏽🤙🏽🤙🏽
On Jan 16, 2021, at 1:45 PM, William Banick <LRTAIJI@xxxxxxxxx> wrote:
Hey Mark,
I understand your question and empathize about wanting this to be strictly
about comic artwork. We certainly have expanded it to All types of
illustrative art. Perhaps we have become too inclusive with other styles.
It is something to consider.
I do not want you feeling picked on as we, like any family, have our
disagreements which have flared up in emails. Feelings have been hurt and
relationships stressed.
At the end of the day, it is nice to peruse and discuss and enjoy.
Sincerely,
Bill
Pursuing the Effortless...
BigFaceLoveYoga.com
🤙🏽🤙🏽🤙🏽
On Jan 16, 2021, at 1:33 PM, Mark D. Nevins <dmarc-noreply@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>
wrote:
Hi Ray:
Given the tone of your e-mail, I'm going to assume that you don't actually
want me to answer your questions. If you would in fact like me to, then
just let me know and I'd be happy to do so, either on-list or privately.
I was most struck in your post by your repeated, emphatic, and insistent use
of the word "banned." I'm not sure where you got that word from. I've
never, ever used that word here, nor have I ever even thought of it in this
context. To the contrary, in every one of my posts on this topic I've
stipulated "I am not interested in dictating anyone's preferences or
collecting interests."
I suppose for me it comes down to respect and kindness. I'd expect that
when a group has a charter as clear as this one (i.e., comic art), people
would respect that. I may love baseball cards, and you may as well, but I'm
not going to insist on dragging my collection into the meetings of the
Detective Fiction Club.
Of course, I may be asking too much on the "respect and kindness" front from
this forum, having in the last 24 hours been groundlessly mischaracterized
as someone who seeks to censor others; told my opinion does not matter; and
called a pedant. So, as you note, there are indeed "multiple issues invoked
in such a discussion" but it really feels like some of them aren't welcome
here. (Are such issues formally banned here, or merely shouted down?)
Having basically been told to shut up on this topic I'll do so, and let
others go on celebrating, for example, adolescent unpublished drawings of
naked superheroines as "comic art." Though in the context of the recent
comments on Marston, Petty, and the problematics of "the male gaze," I
wonder how exactly today's naked Lois Lane drawing fits in....
The culture of this "freelists" comic art group is now clear to me. Can
anyone speak to whether the "groups.io" list might have a different ethos?
Mark Nevins
On Friday, January 15, 2021, 03:20:53 PM EST, RAYMOND CUTHBERT
<rcuthber@xxxxxxx> wrote:
Hi Mark:
Let me ask you a few questions.
Many of the pieces in my collection include pieces like my Alex Raymond
illustrations which were done for non-comic venues.
I have always thought of them as comic-related artwork, even though they are
not comic art. Should such pieces be banned from discussion in this group?
I have recently commissioned Neal Adams to do portraits of several comic
artists. These are not comics since they are not sequential, nor do they
mix drawing with a narrative. Should such pieces be banned from discussion
in this group?
Malcolm recently commissioned Sanjulian to do a marvelous portrait of actor
Sean Connery based upon his role in THE UNTOUCHABLES. Should such pieces
be banned from discussion in this group?
Should paintings by Frank Frazetta done for pocketbook covers be banned for
discussion since they are not sequential, nor do they mix drawing with a
narrative?
Do you have objections to folks discussing comic artist convention sketches
which are clearly not "comic" art since they are not sequential, nor do they
mix drawing with a narrative?
Should sketches such as the ones you have posted by Julie Doucet or Roberta
Gregory be banned from discussion in this group since they are not
sequential, nor do they mix drawing with a narrative?
It seems to me that there are multiple issues invoked in such a discussion.
Best wishes!
- Ray Cuthbert
From: "Mark Nevins" <dmarc-noreply@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>
To: "comicartl" <comicartl@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>
Sent: Friday, January 15, 2021 12:24:16 PM
Subject: [comicart-l] Re: Art Days - James Martin!
Miki,
That’s a really superb collection of SF illustration art. Kudos!
(I’m a big Michael Whelan fan. Whatever happened to him? And Don Maitz too?)
Just to be clear: I love illustration art—my occasional complaint on this
mailing list notwithstanding. It’s just that illustration a different thing
than comic art. Comics are fundamentally about sequential narration.
Illustration is not. This is not a critique of anyone’s taste or collecting
preferences, it’s just a fact.
And yes, I certainly understand cases where “this is an illustration by a
comics artist,” but that’s not really the point. Michael Jordan played both
baseball and basketball professionally: that doesn’t mean those two sports
have anything in common. There are not many NBA players in Cooperstown.
Obviously I’ll deal with it. But I just really don’t see a place for painted
copies of photos of actresses in a comic art gallery, just as I wouldn’t see
a place for fresh vegetables or women’s clothing in a hardware store.
Sorry to be cranky. I guess for me it’s about signal-to-noise ratio. If I
want to look at comic art I’d rather not have to wade through not-comic-art
to do it.
Apparently I’m in the minority.
Cheers,
Mark Nevins
Sent from my iPhone
On Jan 15, 2021, at 12:37, Miki Annamanthadoo <mik1surf1@xxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
Here’s the link to my illustration gallery in CAF
https://www.comicartfans.com/galleryroom.asp?gsub=155962
The first piece is legitimately comic art but I included it in the
illustration gallery because the artist is more recognized as an
illustration artist.
Miki A
On Jan 15, 2021, at 11:04 AM, phillipdanielanderson@xxxxxxxxx wrote:
Is it officially cool to have an illustration section of your CAF now? I
missed that. I don’t have a ton, but am happy to put up what little I have.
On this specific topic. Cool piece Ray!
From: comicartl-bounce@xxxxxxxxxxxxx <comicartl-bounce@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> On
Behalf Of yellowkd@xxxxxxx
Sent: Friday, January 15, 2021 7:02 AM
To: comicartl@xxxxxxxxxxxxx
Subject: [comicart-l] Re: Art Days - James Martin!
Besides Illustration is now a component of CAF including a lot of work by
illustrators who did not work in comics (and while there is a lot of
crossover there are also many who worked solely in illustration.) George
