[argyllcms] Re: Absolute colorimetric - dark saturated colours excessively light

Graeme Gill wrote:

Some folks currently think that things are overly light, and under saturated (e.g. blues and greens).

actually this is my subjective impression as well - strongly saturated out-of-gamut colors are IMO rendered by Argyll's gamut clipping subjectively too ligh and not saturated enough, particularly in comparison to profiles from other profilers which seem to render them darker (resulting in a higher apparent saturation).

Notice that Saturation is not the same as Chroma. According to "Color Appearance Models, 2nd Edition" by Mark Fairchild, Saturation is the "Colorfulness of an area judged in proportion to its Brightness". As a rule of thumb, Fairchild specifies Saturation=Colorfulness/Brightness (chapter 4.8). The various color appearance models eventually use more specific formulas, but most of them do define a Saturation correlate in addition to Chroma (in CIELAB space, no Saturation correlate is officially defined, but only Lightness, Chroma and Hue).

This implies, that Saturation can be increased by increasing Chroma (at constant Lightness), but also by decreasing Lightness (at constant Chroma). So I could imagine that the CUSP point of a gamut hull (in JCh space) for a given Hue angle (i.e. the point with the largest reproducable Chroma at the given hue angle) is not necessarily the most _saturated_ color which can be reproduced at this hue angle (but I have never verified this for real printer gamuts).


Other related posts: