[TechAssist] Re: Acoustic Research speakers AR93Q, repairopinions [FINAL]
- From: Edward Gaidies <teltek@xxxxxxxxxxx>
- To: <techassist@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>
- Date: Mon, 25 Feb 2002 20:41:52 -0500
Gary;
Best thing to do with the old speakers, break off the magnets,sell them to
some boater this summer, when he drops his keys in the water, make great Key
finders. Not worth much more used.
-Ed-
>
> Ed and everyone, thanks for all the great help regarding these speakers.
> I had almost 40 replies. Also, I think I learned quite a lot about
> speaker repairs. Basically it came down to 3 options. 1- obtain new
> original AR woofers & midranges,
> 2- get the original speakers re-surrounded, 3- purchase new replacement
> woofers & midranges (not original parts).
>
> I decided the best thing to do was to call the customer and find out how
> important it was for him to have these speakers in exact original
> condition. His response was that he was not an audio buff who could tell
> the difference at all between original AR sound and generic replacement
> sound, so our discussion lead to me purchasing Crown (by Cambridge
> Speaker) replacement parts. I got them at Cathray trade supply in
> Toronto as mentioned by Ed. All six pieces plus shipping and GST cost me
> only $269 CDN. The woofers are 8 ohm 80W RMS with 60 oz magnet. They
> looked heavier duty than the original AR woofers. They also fit in the
> grooves in the cabinets without me using a router to make the diameter
> larger. The midranges also fit no problem.
>
> The resultant sound was very clear and warm sounding. The customer
> seemed very pleased with the sound and my job repairing them. I do worry
> a bit that the specs may not be 100% correct, such as input impedance,
> Watts RMS,cross-over freq. etc. but I doubt he's gonna blast them at top
> end anyhow. So far I haven't heard back from him with any complaints, so
> I'm calling this one done.
>
>
> I kept the original dud woofers and will later try to sell them on ebay
> to some AR audio buff who might be in need of them. Will wait for a
> while to make sure customer doesn't come back to me regarding repair.
>
>
>
>
>
> Gary McCartney
>
> McCartney Electronics
> 7134 Fife Rd, RR 7
> Guelph Ontario Canada N1H 6J4
> Fax: (519)821-1530
> email: number63@xxxxxxxxxxxxx
>
>
>
>
>
>
> Edward Gaidies wrote:
>>
>> Gary;
>> Just to mention, Cathray is having a moving sale, (on speakers).
>> If you are changing them as a set, Cathray has a good supply of speakers,
>> such as Crown, etc. I believe that Acoustic Research is no longer in
>> business, and what I can remember, they were not a high end speaker, the
>> type that Hi-Fi aficionados would purchase.
>> I'm sure if they are replaced in pairs, they would do quite nicely.
>>
>> -Ed-
>>
>> teltek@xxxxxxxxxxxx
>>
>>>
>>> I have this pair of speakers come into the shop with foam surrounds
>>> desintegrated in all the woofers and midranges. They belong to a doctor
>>> who has given me the go ahead at $400.00 CDN
>>> guest-imate.
>>> I actually gave the price of $400.00 hoping to scare him off because I
>>> don't really feel like doing the job.(I'm not a speaker expert). Didn't
>>> expect him to say that he thought that was a fair price to repair and
>>> that the speakers are worth $1000.00 CDN.
>>>
>>> Ok, so now the problem. Are original parts available for these, and what
>>> cost? If not available, what are replacement options in keeping these
>>> sounding like original?
>>>
>>> The woofers are pn: 200035 (need 4 of them) and midranges are pn: 200036
>>> (need 2 of them)
>>>
>>> All speakers are 8". The woofers measure 8.6 ohm on my meter, or 4.3 ohm
>>> -2 in parallel. The midrange measures 8.6 ohm. I measure 5.4 ohm across
>>> the input terminals of the complete encloser.
>>>
>>> I have posted a web page to show the speakers and the cross over network
>>> schematic.
>>>
>>> http://www.number63.ca/speakers/speakers.html
>>>
>>>
>>> Another option: installing new surrounds. I have attempted this one
>>> other time and it was a flop. The surround I got was just a generic so
>>> maybe that is why. I think I would want proper surrounds to fit these
>>> speakers if I attempt it again. Any pointers in doing this?
>>> Are the surrounds available?
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>> Thanks for any suggestions in how to go about repairing these the best
>>> way.
>>
>> --
>> From: Ed Gaidies
>> teltek@xxxxxxxxxxx
>> Tel-Tek Electronics
>>
>> ------------------------------------------
>> Make your TechAssist database better!
>> Submit Repair Tips here: http://www.tech-assist.org/secure/tip/
>> ------------------------------------------
>> To UNSUBSCRIBE your email address, click here:
>> mailto:techassist-request@xxxxxxxxxxxxx?subject=unsubscribe
>> Or send a BLANK email with unsubscribe in the
>> SUBJECT field to the address above.
-=Ed=-
--
From: Ed Gaidies
teltek@xxxxxxxxxxx (Primary)
teltek2@xxxxxxxxxxxx (Secondary)
teltek35@xxxxxxxxxxx
Tel-Tek Electronics
------------------------------------------
Make your TechAssist database better!
Submit Repair Tips here: http://www.tech-assist.org/secure/tip/
------------------------------------------
To UNSUBSCRIBE your email address, click here:
mailto:techassist-request@xxxxxxxxxxxxx?subject=unsubscribe
Or send a BLANK email with unsubscribe in the
SUBJECT field to the address above.
Other related posts:
