I just received this from Trip Barber on the NAR mailing list. If you're not on it, I have included the message here. So, since High Power motors do not have ejection charges or igniters included, would that mean they should be shipped as flammable solids and not explosives since Judge Walton ruled that they are not "explosives"? Now wouldn't that be ironic. Estes motors would have an explosives packaging but High Power motors would not. Jim G. National Association of Rocketry September 28, 2011 Dear JIM, Several weeks ago the U.S. Department of Transportation (DOT) decided that, based on a 2010 change in some obscure shipping safety test procedures, it should terminate a special shipping exemption that it has granted since 1978 to companies and vendors who ship model rocket motors and igniters. This special exemption, DOT-SP 7887, lets these products which are technically classified as "Explosive 1.4S" get shipped in containers labelled with a black and white "Flammable Solid" hazardous material label rather than a bright orange "Explosives" label. This DOT action will not increase your cost or change your access to the products; the same HAZMAT shipping fee applies in either case and consumers can buy them the same way regardless of how they are labelled in shipping. The issue is one of public perception: we all know that model rocket motors are not going to "blow up" and are not really "explosives" in the way that the public interprets that term. Having them start to show up in schools, hobby stores, and private residences with an alarming orange "Explosives" label on them will simply feed public fears and misperceptions about our safe hobby and these safe products. It will not improve public safety, because shipping them has never posed a risk to that safety. The largest model rocket motor manufacturers, Estes, Quest, and Aerotech, have filed petitions to get this exemption continued rather than canceled. This will be tough to achieve. To help their case they have asked their vendors to send e-mails of support for continuing the exemption to the Department of Transportation Associate Administrator responsible for making this decision. I think that it is in our hobby's interest for us as NAR members to join the manufacturers in this effort. If you would like to be part of this, please cut and paste the text below the dotted line into an e-mail from you to <mailto:specialpermits@xxxxxxx> specialpermits@xxxxxxx as soon as possible, preferably by the end of this coming weekend. Be safe, have fun, and pay forward. Trip Barber President National Association of Rocketry - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - TO: <mailto:specialpermits@xxxxxxx> specialpermits@xxxxxxx Subject: DOT-SP 7887 Show Cause Response Dear Associate Administrator, The purpose of this e-mail is to request that DOT-SP 7887 exemption to ship model rocket motors and igniters in containers marked as "Flammable Solid" rather than as "Explosive 1.4" be kept in force asit has been since 1978. This Special Permit, previously DOT-E 7887, is important to those ofus who enjoy the hobby of model rocketry. To my knowledge, there has never been a fire or safety incident involving the shipping of model rocket motors and igniters, whether by public carrier or USPS. Further I believe that shipping these safe and non-explosive consumer products labelled as "Explosives" will create unnecessary fear and difficulty for those handling, transporting, receiving, storing, selling and using them. Model rockets have a superb safety record and wide public acceptance as a safe product based on 54 years of experience. Having them now start to arrive in consumer hands labelled as explosives could put at risk the reputation that our hobby has earned. After 33 years of use, the termination of the Special Permit is unwarranted and will not contribute to public safety because shipping model rocketsas Flammable Solids has not created any risk to safety. Please keep the Special Permit in place as written. - Your Name and Address (city & state) _____ From: roc-chat-bounce@xxxxxxxxxxxxx [mailto:roc-chat-bounce@xxxxxxxxxxxxx] On Behalf Of JACK GARIBALDI Sent: Tuesday, September 27, 2011 2:05 PM To: Tripoli San Diego List Serv; Roc Chat Subject: [roc-chat] Fw: [TRA-TAP] Fw: URGENT NOTICE FROM AEROTECH ----- Original Message ----- From: W. E. Fred Wallace <mailto:wallacewe@xxxxxxxxxxx> To: TRA <mailto:tap@xxxxxxxxxxx> Technical Advisor Panel Sent: Tuesday, September 27, 2011 1:50 PM Subject: Re: [TRA-TAP] Fw: URGENT NOTICE FROM AEROTECH Obviously it looks like someone has reevaluated their original position (see RP link below).... Fred http://www.rocketryplanet.com/forums/showthread.php?t=9117 PS: I have a copy of the original DOT letter in PDF, if anyone is interested. ----- Original Message ----- From: "JACK GARIBALDI" <JackGaribaldi@xxxxxxx> To: "TAP List" <tap@xxxxxxxxxxx> Sent: Tuesday, September 27, 2011 3:34:03 PM Subject: [TRA-TAP] Fw: URGENT NOTICE FROM AEROTECH Passing on a bulletin that I received today. Jack G ----- Original Message ----- From: AeroTech Customer Service<mailto:customerservice@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> To: All CA & HP Dealers<mailto:customerservice@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> Sent: Tuesday, September 27, 2011 7:40 AM Subject: URGENT NOTICE FROM AEROTECH Dear AeroTech Product Representative: Urgent Notice - Your Immediate Action Is Needed, Send Your E-Mail By October 10, Help preserve your rights regarding model rocketry. Dear AeroTech Customer, Many people are concerned with new government regulations that seem destined to limit our freedoms as well as those that affect our hobbies. You may have heard of some recently that affect various hobbies. New regulations are being considered regarding model rocket motors. This may not immediately impact your access to model rocket materials but it's just another step toward more restrictive regulations concerning our hobby and deserves your attention. The US Department of Transportation (DOT) has recently advised that they propose to terminate a special permit under which model rocket motors and igniters have been shipped for the last 33 years. If the permit is terminated model rocket motors and igniters will no longer be able to be shipped as "Flammable Solids" and will instead have to be shipped as "Explosives." In 33 years there have been no incidents involved in the shipping and transporting of model rocket motors and igniters. The model rocket industry needs your support in order to continue to make our product available. Attached is a sample e-mail that we request you send immediately to express your support. We believe that shipping model rocket motors and igniters as "Explosives" would only cause unnecessary concern for hobby shops, educators, youth group leaders and families using model rockets for educational and recreational purposes. If you believe as we do, please send an e-mail to the Department of Transportation no later than October 10, 2011. To assist you, here is a sample e-mail: -- TO: specialpermits@xxxxxxx <mailto:specialpermits@xxxxxxx%3cmailto:specialpermits@xxxxxxx> <mailto:specialpermits@xxxxxxx> Subject: DOT-SP 7887 Show Cause Response Dear Associate Administrator, The purpose of this e-mail is to request that DOT-SP 7887 be kept in force as written. The Special Permit, previously DOT-E 7887 has been in place since 1978 and is used by many of us who enjoy hobbies including model rockets, motors and igniters. To my knowledge, there has never been an incident involving the shipping and transporting of model rocket motors and igniters. Further I believe that shipping these products as "Explosives" will create unnecessary fear and difficulty for those handling, transporting, receiving, storing, selling and using these products. After 33 years of use, the termination of the Special Permit is unwarranted and possibly damaging to an educational and recreational product that has an excellent record. In closing, I again request the Special Permit be kept in place as written. - Your Name and Address -- Please take a few minutes to send your e-mail today! Thank you very much for your support of model rocketry. --- Sincerely, RCS, Inc. AeroTech Division 2113 W 850 N Cedar City, UT 84721 Ph: 435-865-7100 Ext. 104 Fax: 435-865-7120 Email: customerservice@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx