> Subject: Re: [geocentrism] Re: Fw: Airy and the telescope... I would > point out that if there were an aether, the doppler shift > formulae for light and sound would be the same. They're not! > > Alan > Steve wrote: >> So Alan, Are you saying that light is longitudinal? I could go for >> that...but I don't think that you are :-) I mean let's talk apples >> to apples. Yes, let's talk apples to apples, now we're really getting to the core of it. If a wave propagates by displacement of a medium and you move relative to that medium then your speed will affect the apparent speed of the wave: classic doppler effect. Light however doesn't behave like this, the frequency changes almost as you'd expect but the speed stays the same irrespective of your movement. Although this seems completely counter intuitive, as the evidence mounted up scientists were reluctantly forced to drop their hypothesis of an aether because of this. What Doppler himself thought about light is irrelevant. Regards, Mike.