I think so too...it should remain open particularly for the valuable information. Sent from my BlackBerry® Smartphone, from Etisalat. Enjoy high speed internet service with Etisalat easy net, available at all our experience centres -----Original Message----- From: Aftermath <aftermath.thegreat@xxxxxxxxx> Sender: cryptome-bounce@xxxxxxxxxxxxx Date: Fri, 26 Jul 2013 10:42:58 To: <cryptome@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> Reply-To: cryptome@xxxxxxxxxxxxx Subject: [cryptome] Re: Freelists As Well As NSA Snooping Addendum I think this mailing list is another fine way to exchange information and Ideas. please dont close it On Fri, Jul 26, 2013 at 6:48 AM, Ben McGinnes <ben@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote: > On 26/07/13 9:57 PM, John Young wrote: > > > > Cryptome does not support secret forums, instead participants should > > know contents are public before joining a forum or participating. > > I blame webmail. Ever since people stopped looking at email in a mail > client, they started treating mailing lists like reddit or some PHP > forum. > > > This list has had little traffic and only a small number of > > posters. That's a fine alternative to social media frenzy of aiding > > official and commercial spying that is fostering the unwary frenzy > > to harvest its "free" bounty. > > Certainly freelists.org isn't the best option given what you want, but > there are alternatives. > > > We add on the possible list closing, all messages will be deleted, > > subscriber list too. > > > > But, destroying public information is abominable, so we are open to > > persuasion on this. > > What I would do is this: > > 1) Fine a new service that provides complete control, e.g. like that > offered by RiseUp: https://www.riseup.net/en/lists > > 2) Create the new list, play with the settings, test it. > > 3) Either disable the archive entirely or restrict it to subscribers > only. > > 4) Announce the new list on the old list for people to subscribe and > post to with links to the relevant guides. Warn the subscribers > about step 5 and what to expect (which you should know from testing > in step 2). > > 5) Mass subscribe the entire list of subscribers to the new list. > > 6) Prevent further posting to the old list and make a copy of the > entire archive at that point (e.g. as a .zip file). > > 7) If there's a file share for the new list, upload the copy of the > old archive for subscriber access only. > > 8) Delete the old list, including the archive and subscriber list. > > That's it. > > Oh, I used riseup.net in the example because they provide services to > activists and are big on privacy, even on mailing lists. The only > potential drawback is whether you'd class Cryptome as radical in the > same way as they would. I'd be surprised if they took that tack given > all the stuff you publish, but who knows. > > > Regards, > Ben > >