Joan, as a previous sittting Board Member, did you get Board approval prior to using Helms Birscoe OR your #5 listed below? I cannot find it in any of the Board minutes. Helen Msg: #7 in digest From: "Joan Fox" <campaigners@xxxxxxxxxxxx> Subject: Helms/Briscoe Date: Mon, 21 May 2007 20:12:12 -0400 If anyone has any further questions as to how this company worked with myself and Nanci other than what I will post here please feel free to call me. I will try not to leave anything out and will look up any answers in my letter file, if needed. I will not respond to the misinformation on this list as it seems to serve no purpose and I hope this helps set the record straight. 1) PAYMENT: We do not pay Helms/Briscoe. 2) CONVENTION CENTERS: They only have booked hotel/motel rooms for us. 2) MONEY SAVED FOR THE CLUB:They have gotten us much better rates at hotels we have and will be using than I could get by going directly to the hotel/motels and through the business meeting planners for them. They have great leverage and have been responsible for many of the amenities this Board has utilized and monies saved. I double checked almost each one and they always had the lowest rate.This was all done to save the club money and less work for Nanci and myself. 3) DOUBLE COVERAGE: They work directly with the CVB's, but have the advantage of also being able to make other hotels/motels known to us. The CVB's can only recommend hotels that are paying members of that group.. Both Helms/Briscoe and the CVB's are given the requirements as listed in the National Show Checklist as written by Nanci and Lea. This is what I was told to work with and comply with where at all possible. This may be read in the P&P on the GSDCA website in Section XII. 4) HILTON FACTS: The Hilton contract was not "shot down:" It expired as no one on the Board knew about it. Helms/Briscoe found out about it and also notified me that none of the other proposed hotels had contracts and Fall is ski season in Utah. Hotels rooms get scarce and very expensive. They then quickly contacted the hotels that were on the list to get us what was proposed until the Show Chair could see them. This was done as a safety measure. Nanci was privy to the mails. She was unable to inspect the hotels/motels until April of this year unfortunately and the list was reworked. Thank goodness! It seems to me that all is well that ends well for the members. These problems will not be repeated due to unusual circumstances in transition. H/Briscoe is,and was, agreeable that only hotels we are comfortable with be booked. It is no ones fault that this was not able to be done until recently. Just to reiterate... this is not part of my job. Nanci has the final say so on what hotels are used. I never saw them as I deferred to her although I offered to go earlier if she wanted as we were all concerned. The Hilton contract had to be renewed by Jan. 2006 or be penalized. This was reported at the October meeting. Copies of the old contract were obtained by Helms/Briscoe and sent to Lew and Nanci and myself. This problem was addressed by the Executive Committee and then readdressed recently by Lew and Nanci. Luckily, what could have been a disaster has been diverted. Helms/Briscoe could not involve themselves in straightening out this contract,as they Board wanted, as they were not part of the transaction. Just to reiterate.. Helms/Briscoe did not recommend the hotels on the original list. 5) When I visited the the over 20 show sites in the East, West, and Central regions in a 16 month period........ I looked at motel/hotels each time at sites that might be workable. There is no sense in considering a site without this information. This usually entailed an added 2 day period to each visit. With travel, a week is really needed to look at each site. Helms/Briscoe and the local CVB's both helped with the room inspections. We all worked together to find properties that were suitable as I sent them what we required and as you can imagine I rejected many places. Our goal was to find app. 500 dog friendly rooms at each one. That can be difficult as many places were not willing to commit for 2 to 3 years out. The CVB's have met with me on almost all the inspections. Any proposed hotels have been investigated and H/B had contracts in place in case we did choose a site. As rates at properties will rise over a 3 year period we had them agree to quote today's prices to save the club and members money. Allot of work and expense with no security that the Board would even consider a site let alone visit or contract it. 6) Helms/Briscoe is being utilized by other National Dog Club people. They first contacted me through Bill Pfeiffer and he called me and we thought it was worth a try and Lew agreed. The Board discussed it, I believe in Oct and in Jan. We have no contract and do not have to use them. Therefore, no motion was needed to utilize them as this was a trial basis. We don't get Motions on everything needed to make this club work. We would get nothing done. A Chairman makes decisions as how to operate their committee unless GSDCA funds are needed and then anything over $700 needs Board approval. Also, all contracts have to be signed by the Pres. and the Treas. 7) H/B was working with airlines for us for better pricing for the Board meetings and members. 8) It is my hope to be able to work with Nancy and generate a system whereby the members could get hotel information earlier than June so the impression of favoritism in rooms could be dispelled. Also, this would result in the approved hotels being booked first. 9) The hotels decide how many rooms they will release to a group based on company policy. This is not a GSDCA decision. If you have read this far, I thank you, Joan. Joan Fox GSDCA National Show Site Chairman GSDCA Board Meeting Sites Chairman GSDCA Policy and Procedures Chairman GSDCA Board Members Orientation Guide Chairman 440-543-9165 Home phone 440-759-4119 Cell phone 440-543-9165 Fax <http://www.campaignersgsds.com/> http://www.campaignersgsds.com/ ============================================================================ POST is Copyrighted 2007. All material remains the property of the original author and of GSD Communication, Inc. NO REPRODUCTIONS or FORWARDS of any kind are permitted without prior permission of the original author AND of the Showgsd-l Management. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. ALL PERSONS ARE ON NOTICE THAT THE FORWARDING, REPRODUCTION OR USE IN ANY MANNER OF ANY MATERIAL WHICH APPEARS ON SHOWGSD-L WITHOUT THE EXPRESS PERMISSION OF ALL PARTIES TO THE POST AND THE LIST MANAGEMENT IS EXPRESSLY FORBIDDEN, AND IS A VIOLATION OF LAW. VIOLATORS OF THIS PROHIBITION WILL BE PROSECUTED. For assistance, please contact the List Management at admin@xxxxxxxxxxxx VISIT OUR WEBSITE - www.showgsd.org ============================================================================