Hi Bruce, The "B" solution is a saturated solution (100%) of Potassium Carbonate, a satureted solution of Sodium Carbonate will not be the same, it will be less active since you can solute less Sodium Carbonate to the "max"... There are older formula's of PyrocatHD which use 10% sodium carbonate as part B (obviously you have to add more..) Best, Cor -----Original Message----- From: pure-silver-bounce@xxxxxxxxxxxxx [mailto:pure-silver-bounce@xxxxxxxxxxxxx]On Behalf Of Camclicker@xxxxxxx Sent: vrijdag 2 september 2005 17:20 To: pure-silver@xxxxxxxxxxxxx Subject: [pure-silver] POTASSIUM -Vs- SODIUM... ...CARBONATE The formula for Pyrocat HD that I have calls for 75 g Potassium Carbonate in Part B. The "Calls For, You Got" section of the Cookbook suggests Sodium Carbonate can be used in place of Potassium by using 1.12 time the amount of Potassium. I don't question this to be true but there must be a difference in the final product -- no? If you don't use Potassium won't you loose something or gain something you probably don't want? Or are the results interpreted as equal? Bruce Brooklyn, NY camclicker@xxxxxxx www.camclicker.com