Craig Birkmaier wrote: > Make up your mind Bert. Above you state that the DBS portion > is becoming unnecessary. Now you say the article makes a big > deal about retention of DBS to the home. What's not to get? I said that the article's rationalization for retaining the DBS broadcast portion of the service to homes IS MISPLACED. I commented on something I find illogical, in the article. Had the article said nothing objectionable, I would most likely not have commented. > By the way Bert, did you catch the comment from Ergen about > using Hopper to deliver targeted ads via DBS to their > subscribers? Yes, but sorry, that aspect has a way of making me yawn. In short, it is IMO very reasonable for the DBS folk to completely reinvent themselves as two-way wireless broadband services. It would make more sense to me, for example (just one possibility here) if they would buy a cellular company, and all its cellular spectrum, for providing this new IP-based service in higher density locations. And then dedicate their entire satellite service to two-way broadband for rural locations. That rural broadband is their one ace in the hole, for now anyway, so it makes sense to maximize its usefulness. (I'm not sure how much flexibility they have in their satellite transponders, to make this kind of switch.) The cable(d) companies can of course make the switch more easily, to prevalently broadband IP vs. the current system of one-way broadcast TV tiers taking up most of their infrastructure's capacity. Like it or not, as people get used to watching TV over IP, they won't think of it like something strange. They'll think of it like something obvious. Which means, they will lose interest in the one-way delivery of TV service tiers. So advertisers and content owners are already paying more attention to this shift, as the multiple articles have reported. Bert ---------------------------------------------------------------------- You can UNSUBSCRIBE from the OpenDTV list in two ways: - Using the UNSUBSCRIBE command in your user configuration settings at FreeLists.org - By sending a message to: opendtv-request@xxxxxxxxxxxxx with the word unsubscribe in the subject line.