On 6/17/06, Omar Kusturica <omarkusto@xxxxxxxxx> wrote:
--- wokshevs@xxxxxx wrote:
> Quoting Omar Kusturica <omarkusto@xxxxxxxxx>: > > > > One question that one might put to the > > historicists/culturalists is, do they think that > their > > own ideas are only valid within their own > > geo-historical location ? > > You render the question as an empirical one, and, > hence, it is without any > philosophical interest. The interesting > philosophical (epistemological) > question is whether they have an epistemic right to > believe otherwise.
*I think that most of us here are old enough and literate enough to see that this is what I was getting at. There is however an empirical element to the question because I would be interested to hear what they think about this.
We have, I believe, reached a fundamental disagreement. Walter's demand for absolute, nonempirical knowledge is, outside of mathematics and other forms of the glass bead game, something I outgrew around 1965, when I looked at what I'd learned doing a B.A. in Philosophy and decided to go for a Ph.D. in social anthropology.
I recall a famous joke about three men on a desert island. All they have to eat is a can of beans. The Chemist calculates how hot their fire will have to be to make the can explode. The Physicist calculates how far the beans will fly and places leaves to catch them. The Economist says, "Assume a can opener."
The Philosopher imagined by Walter strikes me as being very like that Economist, with this important difference. The Economist's assumed can opener reminds me that there may be something else, a rock for example, that will serve in place of a can opener. The Philosopher's "Assume a transcendental" points to nothing at all.
Or, if it points to anything, it points to the human habit of making assumptions, a pretty solid matter of fact, which leads to the useful question, "What are they assuming?" The answer depends on empirical evidence, words and things, and is rarely found by navel-gazing.
-- John McCreery The Word Works, Ltd., Yokohama, JAPAN
US CITIZEN ABROAD? YOU'RE THE DECIDER! Register to Vote in '06 Elections www.VoteFromAbroad.org ------------------------------------------------------------------ To change your Lit-Ideas settings (subscribe/unsub, vacation on/off, digest on/off), visit www.andreas.com/faq-lit-ideas.html