i will check this out. Where did you find the MSDS? Never crossed my mind to use that as a reference. I will check the Morgan and Morgan Index tomorrow when i go into the lab to see if they list the formula for this toner. I believe Tim Rudman list a direct gold-thiocarbamide toner that also contains citric acid,however it has a very short life after mixing. Thanks to all . ann -------------- Original message -------------- > > ----- Original Message ----- > From: > To: > Sent: Tuesday, December 07, 2004 11:04 AM > Subject: [pure-silver] substitute for commercial gold toner > > > > Have been using Fotospeed gold toner and am looking for > > formula that i can mix my self , as i have on hand a wide > > variety of chemical used for other gold toners. This toner > > is being used after selenium for extended times, long > > extended times with no color shifts. > > Fotospeed does not list the basic ingredients as do many > > other makers so I don't know what they are using that > > makes it so stable that it can be used, put away and then > > re-used again. > > > > I have been doing a lot of research and have almost every > > known formula. Have also talked with the Formulary > > regarding their kits to determine what would be a similar > > substitute. > > > > It has boiled down to GAF 231 or perhapes GP-1. > > > > Both contain basically the same chemicals; in varying > > amounts. I have used GP-1 when doing split toning > > (Jonathan Bailey's version) but it is also recommend for > > basic protection rather than a color shift. 231 can and > > will produce a color shift but it's discription is similar > > to the one found on Fotospeeds directions. One indicates > > the use of Ammonium thiocyanate altho Sodium thiocyanate > > may be subsituted. the other indicates sodium thiocyanate > > with Potassium thiocyanate may be subsituted. In my Morgan > > and Mortgan index all version of thiocyanate indicate > > their can be a substitution of any the other types. > > My question is does it make a difference (am not a > > chemist, so i don't know)? What i do know is that there is > > huge difference in cost. > > > > It would be nice to find a substitute that could be mixed > > and have on hand to use at a moments notice, which is one > > advantage that Fotospeed provides. > > > > Any thoughts? > > > > regards, > > ann clancy > > > The MSDS for the Fotospeed Gold toner indicates it > contains Thiourea (AKA Thiocarbamide). I think this is what > is used in Kodak GP-2, a gold toner intended for image > protection of microfilm. I don't remember seeing another > Gold toner of this type but there probably are others. > I don't know how much if any difference the type of salt > makes with thiocyanate, my guess is little or none. > > --- > Richard Knoppow > Los Angeles, CA, USA > dickburk@xxxxxxxxxxxxx > > ================================================================================ > > ============================= > To unsubscribe from this list, go to www.freelists.org and logon to your > account > (the same e-mail address and password you set-up when you subscribed,) and > unsubscribe from there. ============================================================================================================= To unsubscribe from this list, go to www.freelists.org and logon to your account (the same e-mail address and password you set-up when you subscribed,) and unsubscribe from there.