[vipaudioaccess] Re: SV: Re: Melodyne update news, it's not good.

  • From: Jean-philippe Rykiel <jprykiel@xxxxxxxxx>
  • To: vipaudioaccess@xxxxxxxxxxxxx
  • Date: Fri, 6 May 2022 14:59:30 +0200

Hi Steve. I don't know if you gave them this kind of argument, but this is the way I see things.

Companies are spending a certain amount of Time and money to add new features to their products. They don't know if people will like these new features, they just do it without knowing what will be Their clients response. So, why not take 10% of this time and money and spend it on new features that will only but surely be loved by a certain percentage of their users. Maybe not 10%, maybe just 1% but it's still something.

Best,

JPR



http://www.jprykiel.com
https://www.youtube.com/c/jprykiel
http://soundcloud.com/ryksounet
https://www.youtube.com/c/jprykielhttp://facebook.com/jeanphilipperykiel

Le 06/05/2022 à 14:39, Steve Spamer a écrit :


Thanks JP.

Well, I’ve had some more dialog with Celemony, so I’m just awaiting their reply. It might be an option, but we’ll see how it goes for now. Funnily enough, they are aware of this conversation we’re having on list. I know they are aware of our frustrations, which we often have across the board when the subject of accessibility is the subject. We of course have a huge frustration with this problem, but it’s not directed specifically at them, it’s a wider issue that we’re all too aware of, they just happen to be the ones in the firing line at the moment.

I have no doubt that they are under a lot of pressure and they have very limited resources, so their hands maybe tied, but I hope that at least we are able to convince them to keep the status quo.

Best steve.

Samplitude Access-The Gateway To Pro Recording With Samplitude For the Visually Impaired: www.samplitudeaccess.org.uk <http://www.samplitudeaccess.org.uk>
Follow me on Twitter:
stevesax123
Contact me:
Mobile:
+44 (0)7733373714
E-Mail:
stevespamer68@xxxxxxxxx

*From:*vipaudioaccess-bounce@xxxxxxxxxxxxx <vipaudioaccess-bounce@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> *On Behalf Of *Jean-philippe Rykiel
*Sent:* 06 May 2022 12:36
*To:* vipaudioaccess@xxxxxxxxxxxxx
*Subject:* [vipaudioaccess] Re: SV: Re: Melodyne update news, it's not good.

Hey Steve,

I did that two days ago, and reiterated this morning On their Facebook page. The reply on Facebook was, dear JPR, your support ticket is with us, thanks for letting us know.

If your video is available, I could also post it there if you think that's necessary. It could reach more people you know...

Cheers,

JPR

http://www.jprykiel.com
https://www.youtube.com/c/jprykiel
http://soundcloud.com/ryksounet
https://www.youtube.com/c/jprykielhttp://facebook.com/jeanphilipperykiel  ;
<https://www.youtube.com/c/jprykielhttp:/facebook.com/jeanphilipperykiel>

Le 06/05/2022 à 12:54, Steve Spamer a écrit :

    Hi JP.

    Yes, absolutely, this is what users need to do to at least make
    Celemony aware that we’re not happy. So, please please please, if
    you can take a couple of minutes out of your day to send Celemony
    a quick message whith concerns over this move to inaccessibility,
    then you can write to:

    support@xxxxxxxxxxxx

    BTW JP. Regarding your idea of show-casing my solution, well I’ve
    already done that, as I have reported 1 bug and requested a
    feature. I found a bug in ARA and asked them to add the ability to
    play a selection via a keystroke. Ironically, they confirmed the
    bug, fixed it and introduced the feature in this latest update. To
    do that, I used my solution and sent them a video. On the back of
    that video, they actually gave me an NFR copy of Melodyne Studio,
    because they were very impressed with how it worked. Again, the
    irony is, I can’t use this version they’ve released lol!

    Anyway, just to reiterate, please folks, write to them, this is
    the only way they will accept that this community is worth
    accommodating for.

    Best steve.

    Samplitude Access-The Gateway To Pro Recording With Samplitude For
    the Visually Impaired: www.samplitudeaccess.org.uk
    <http://www.samplitudeaccess.org.uk>
    Follow me on Twitter:
    stevesax123
    Contact me:
    Mobile:
    +44 (0)7733373714
    E-Mail:
    stevespamer68@xxxxxxxxx

    *From:*vipaudioaccess-bounce@xxxxxxxxxxxxx
    <vipaudioaccess-bounce@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>
    <mailto:vipaudioaccess-bounce@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> *On Behalf Of
    *Jean-philippe Rykiel
    *Sent:* 06 May 2022 07:44
    *To:* vipaudioaccess@xxxxxxxxxxxxx
    *Subject:* [vipaudioaccess] Re: SV: Re: Melodyne update news, it's
    not good.

    Hi Brian,

    this is exactly what I did two days ago, still waiting for their
    reply.

    Steve, one thing you could do maybe, is demo what your script is
    able to do in a video, Along with a short history of Melodyne's
    accessibility, And ending with saying, all right, this is what we
    were able to do until last version came out and broke it all, and
    I will post it to Celemony's Facebook page. That might tickle them
    a bit I think.

    http://www.jprykiel.com

    https://www.youtube.com/c/jprykiel

    http://soundcloud.com/ryksounet

    https://www.youtube.com/c/jprykielhttp://facebook.com/jeanphilipperykiel  ;
<https://www.youtube.com/c/jprykielhttp:/facebook.com/jeanphilipperykiel>

    Le 05/05/2022 à 23:48, Brian hovmand Olesen (brian) a écrit :

        Hi,

        I think all of us, who actually board the program should
        contact Celemony,  and kindly ask them to revert to the former
        platform, or do something else, so we visually impaired users
        still can use it properly.

        Luckily not many significant enhancements has been made to the
        newly released 5.2 that we can’t live without, but in the
        future this is going to be a serious problem.

        Best regards

        Brian

        *Fra:* vipaudioaccess-bounce@xxxxxxxxxxxxx <> *På vegne af
        *ptorpey00@xxxxxxxxx
        *Sendt:* 5. maj 2022 22:46
        *Til:* vipaudioaccess@xxxxxxxxxxxxx
        *Emne:* [vipaudioaccess] Re: Melodyne update news, it's not good.

        The sad thing is that such a tool as SKIA even exists.  If
        SKIA had built in accessibility in the first place, folks who
        built their tools on this platform would then be accessible.
        Since this is a free, open source tool, it isn’t surprising
        that developers want to use it.  On the other hand, being a
        Google sponsored and managed project it is shameful that
        Google doesn’t either make this accessible or clearly indicate
        that to developers as a major caveat.

        --Pete

        *From:*vipaudioaccess-bounce@xxxxxxxxxxxxx
        <vipaudioaccess-bounce@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>
        <mailto:vipaudioaccess-bounce@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> *On Behalf Of
        *Steve Spamer
        *Sent:* Thursday, May 5, 2022 2:35 PM
        *To:* vipaudioaccess@xxxxxxxxxxxxx
        *Subject:* [vipaudioaccess] Re: Melodyne update news, it's not
        good.

        Phil, they are now using Skia to draw everything on screen.
        That graphics engine has no direct option for accessibility by
        default, but it apparently has a framework built in that
        Flutter can utilise. So, currently, what Skia draws, Skia
        doesn’t care about, there is no way to tell Skia what is or
        isn’t text, it all just appears as non readable pictures really.

        I have no idea how Skia and Flutter differ, but after having
        dialog with Vic Tsaran, he’s assured us that accessibility can
        be added if they are willing to add the necessary code with
        Flutter. Now whether or not they are willing to do this is the
        million dollar question.

        The dev at Celemony I’ve been having communication with has
        said the same old stuff we’ve heard a thousand times before,
        in as much as they’re a small team and they have little
        resources to address problems like this. He did however, say
        that he wants to evaluate whether or not there is “any low
        hanging fruit” they can grab…which I take to mean, is there
        any money to be made out of doing this.

        Anyway, there are a handful of us who are trying our best to
        urge Celemony to go down this route…and there is the knowledge
        in this group to give Celemony the information to achieve it,
        so we’ll see if we get any joy.

        Best steve.

        Samplitude Access-The Gateway To Pro Recording With Samplitude
        For the Visually Impaired: www.samplitudeaccess.org.uk
        <http://www.samplitudeaccess.org.uk>
        Follow me on Twitter:
        stevesax123
        Contact me:
        Mobile:
        +44 (0)7733373714
        E-Mail:
        stevespamer68@xxxxxxxxx

        *From:*vipaudioaccess-bounce@xxxxxxxxxxxxx
        <vipaudioaccess-bounce@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> *On Behalf Of *Phil Muir
        *Sent:* 05 May 2022 20:26
        *To:* vipaudioaccess@xxxxxxxxxxxxx
        *Subject:* [vipaudioaccess] Re: Melodyne update news, it's not
        good.

        I have been following this thread.  I wonder what Celemony are
        using to author their plug-ins? For example, if they are
        written in Juce or QT then graphics libraries shouldn’t come
        into play as they can use the accessibility UI to help us.  As
        you know, Skia is used on Android, Chrome etc.  This isn’t an
        issue as Android has accessibility API’s as indeed does Chrome.

        *From:*vipaudioaccess-bounce@xxxxxxxxxxxxx
        <vipaudioaccess-bounce@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> *On Behalf Of *Steve Spamer
        *Sent:* 05 May 2022 10:17
        *To:* vipaudioaccess@xxxxxxxxxxxxx
        *Subject:* [vipaudioaccess] Re: Melodyne update news, it's not
        good.

        I’m guessing that some companies are doing this because it’s
        the easiest way for cross platform compatibility, e.g. so
        their products work on Windows and IOS. Like I said, my
        thoughts are they’re doing this to support the new M1 silicon
        chipset from Apple.

        I have to say, after reading a bit more about skia, it really
        is a super lazy/backwards step move on Celemony’s part. Our
        only hope is that there is another tool that works in
        conjunction with Skia to give them the tools to add some
        accessibility, as Skia doesn’t have anything to offer at all!

        It’s just a fact of life that we get the shitty end of the
        stick more times then not, they see our community as
        disposable, yet they will jump through hoops to provide eye
        candy for the sighted user. There maybe some dialog to have
        with Celemony, but we’ll have to see how that goes, I’m not
        too positive about it, but I think we have to try. My heart
        wants to do everything to make these people take
        responsibility, but my head says it won’t achieve anything,
        only calm/positive dialog really get’s anywhere.

        Best steve.

        Samplitude Access-The Gateway To Pro Recording With Samplitude
        For the Visually Impaired: www.samplitudeaccess.org.uk
        <http://www.samplitudeaccess.org.uk>
        Follow me on Twitter:
        stevesax123
        Contact me:
        Mobile:
        +44 (0)7733373714
        E-Mail:
        stevespamer68@xxxxxxxxx

        *From:*vipaudioaccess-bounce@xxxxxxxxxxxxx
        <vipaudioaccess-bounce@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> *On Behalf Of
        *il@xxxxxxxxxxxxx
        *Sent:* 05 May 2022 08:02
        *To:* vipaudioaccess@xxxxxxxxxxxxx
        *Subject:* [vipaudioaccess] Re: Melodyne update news, it's not
        good.

        Indeed, if I remember right, it’s why Microsoft and Apple
        pursued built in access.  But hey, what can us VIs do?

        Ian

        *From:*vipaudioaccess-bounce@xxxxxxxxxxxxx
        <vipaudioaccess-bounce@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> *On Behalf Of
        *Jean-Philippe Rykiel
        *Sent:* 05 May 2022 07:49
        *To:* vipaudioaccess@xxxxxxxxxxxxx
        *Subject:* [vipaudioaccess] Re: Melodyne update news, it's not
        good.

        I hear you Ian, but you know,  I’ve always wondered why some
        companies care about accessibility and some don’t. It doesn’t
        seem to be a money problem at all in fact, but more an
        individual sensitivity matter. Who knows if someone at the top
        of the pyramid at native instruments ableton or modartt  does
        not have a close friend or member of his family who is blind.
        I really wonder.

        Cheers,

        JPR

        http://www.jprykiel.com

        http://soundcloud.com/ryksounet

        https://www.youtube.com/c/jprykiel

        Http://www.facebook.com/jprykiel
        <Http://www.facebook.com/jprykiel>

            Le 5 mai 2022 à 08:36, il@xxxxxxxxxxxxx a écrit :

            Hi JP

            Kind of interesting, but I think what it does is
            high-light the problem.  If we tried fighting a battle in
            the UK, we would probably be confounded by the fact many
            of these companies are American.  We fight it in the
            States, other parts of the World would be left behind.
             The route of the problem is that people studying software
            development at University aren't being made to face
            there's a wider World out there that includes people with
            access issues.  There needs to be a fundamental change in
            how software development is taught.  If access was
            included at the beginning of many of these programs we try
            and use I'm sure the World would be a more equal place... 😊

            Best

            Ian

            -----Original Message-----
            From: vipaudioaccess-bounce@xxxxxxxxxxxxx
            <vipaudioaccess-bounce@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> On Behalf Of
            Jean-philippe Rykiel
            Sent: 05 May 2022 06:46
            To: vipaudioaccess@xxxxxxxxxxxxx
            Subject: [vipaudioaccess] Re: Melodyne update news, it's
            not good.

            Hey guys,

            there is this website I receive newsletter from every once
            in a while.
            No idea if it could help at all but here is the link.

            http://lflegal.com/2015/08/legal-update-summer15/

            Forgive me if it's irrelevant.

            Cheers,

            JPR

            http://www.jprykiel.com
            https://www.youtube.com/c/jprykiel
            http://soundcloud.com/ryksounet
            
https://www.youtube.com/c/jprykielhttp://facebook.com/jeanphilipperykiel
            
<https://www.youtube.com/c/jprykielhttp:/facebook.com/jeanphilipperykiel>

            Le 05/05/2022 à 03:25, James Malone a écrit :

                Hey Steve, is this update automatic? Ian, can't
                remember how many times I went down this road. I even
                sent spectra sonics to the better business bureau, and
                they told me that because of the lack of interest in
                regards to us controlling the market they weren't
                going to make allowances for us. They even ask me to
                remove them from the list.

                I said no.

                Jim

                -----Original Message-----

                From: vipaudioaccess-bounce@xxxxxxxxxxxxx

                <vipaudioaccess-bounce@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> On Behalf Of
                Steve Spamer

                Sent: Wednesday, May 4, 2022 12:17 PM

                To: vipaudioaccess@xxxxxxxxxxxxx

                Subject: [vipaudioaccess] Re: Melodyne update news,
                it's not good.

                Hey Ian, I totally feel the pain as well!

                I've had this with Spectrasonics before. They just
                decide to change their graphics engine with no
                consultation on the affects it has on their user base.
                It's almost as if they're happy to take your money,
                but then are quite happy to take away the product you
                paid for!

                All of this is a thankless task and it does make you
                question why you

                do it, but while what I do empowers other VIP's, then
                I guess I'll try

                my best to keep things going, but I do agree, there
                has to be a

                breaking point...and the trouble is, this seems to be
                happening more

                and more with the same old excuses that budgets don't
                stretch to

                accessibility! It's as if we take 2 steps forward and
                then 3 steps

                back!!! 😒😖

                Best Steve.

                -----Original Message-----

                From: vipaudioaccess-bounce@xxxxxxxxxxxxx

                <vipaudioaccess-bounce@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> On Behalf Of
                il@xxxxxxxxxxxxx

                Sent: 04 May 2022 18:07

                To: vipaudioaccess@xxxxxxxxxxxxx

                Subject: [vipaudioaccess] Re: Melodyne update news,
                it's not good.

                Hi Steve

                It makes me so mad, all that work you've put in wiped
                out in a moment.  Not wanting to sound overly dramatic
                about this, but, enough is enough.  The lack of access
                to these 2 bit programs is discriminatory.  Enough
                noise has been made about access in the last 5 years,
                they surely can't say they don't know anything about
                it.  We're getting to the stage where we need to make
                an example of one of these software providers and sue
                their fucking arses...  Really, does anyone out there
                have a lawyer friend?  Would they be interested in
                taking this on?

                If not sue them, then try and get people to boycott them.

                OK, that's out my system.

                All the best

                Ian

                -----Original Message-----

                From: vipaudioaccess-bounce@xxxxxxxxxxxxx

                <vipaudioaccess-bounce@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> On Behalf Of
                Steve Spamer

                Sent: 04 May 2022 15:07

                To: vipaudioaccess@xxxxxxxxxxxxx

                Subject: [vipaudioaccess] Re: Melodyne update news,
                it's not good.

                Hi Floyd.

                Oh, gotcha, yes that's the plan. Scripts will be done
                by the end of today , so it's just tidying up the
                documentation and making videos. I do think there will
                be a few different videos, as I want to explain each
                concept separately, e.g. navigation, selecting blobs,
                splitting blobs , removing separations etc. Also, as
                the scripts support the stand alone, ARA and plugin
                flavours of Melodyne, along with each version,
                Essential, Assistant, Editor and Studio, there are
                some things you can do in 1, but not another, plus the
                plugin version has a couple of slight differences, due
                to what you need to do after a transfer.

                Best Steve.

                -----Original Message-----

                From: vipaudioaccess-bounce@xxxxxxxxxxxxx

                <vipaudioaccess-bounce@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> On Behalf Of
                floyd white

                Sent: 04 May 2022 13:13

                To: vipaudioaccess@xxxxxxxxxxxxx

                Subject: [vipaudioaccess] Re: Melodyne update news,
                it's not good.

                Hi Steve,

                Yup, I got that.

                My question is, do you plan to put your scripts up
                with an 'how to'

                video for the Samplitude versions we already have?

                I'm still happily using version 5 here.

                Perhaps with a charge like Vallahalla?

                Thanks,

                Floyd...

                On 5/4/22, Steve Spamer <stevespamer68@xxxxxxxxx> wrote:

                    Hi Floyd.

                    It's only this latest Melodyne update, which is
                    supposed to be a

                    minor update BTW that now shows no text on screen
                    for a screen

                    reader, the previous version is still OK in that
                    regard. So, you can

                    still use this build in any up to date DAW like
                    Samplitude.

                    I'm communicating with others to see if there are
                    any avenues to

                    investigate to see if we can get Celemony to at
                    least make it how it

                    was prior to this update. I can't see them doing
                    anything major, but

                    there maybe possibilities that they might
                    consider. They've moved to

                    a new graphics platform called Skia...and if there
                    are options to add

                    accessibility using this platform, there might be
                    some hope moving forward.

                    BTW, the more I read about changes companies are
                    making in regards to

                    what UI platform they use, the more Apple M1
                    silicon chips crop up.

                    Spectrasonics have done it...and I know they did
                    it for this reason,

                    now it looks like Celemony have also done it. So,
                    it looks like we're

                    losing accessibility, because of Apple changes 😖.

                    Best Steve.

                    -----Original Message-----

                    From: vipaudioaccess-bounce@xxxxxxxxxxxxx

                    <vipaudioaccess-bounce@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> On Behalf Of
                    floyd white

                    Sent: 04 May 2022 03:18

                    To: vipaudioaccess@xxxxxxxxxxxxx

                    Subject: [vipaudioaccess] Re: Melodyne update
                    news, it's not good.

                    Bummer Steve,

                    This is pretty much what happened with Sonar and
                    CakeTalking.

                    Do you plan to put up the scripts with a video
                    perhaps for we that

                    have older versions like with Samplitude 5 or 6?

                    By the way, Google, though it professes to be the
                    cat's meow for

                    accessibility has lots and lots of issues in a
                    number of their products.

                    Thanks for everything you do,

                    Floyd...

                    On 5/3/22, Steve Spamer <stevespamer68@xxxxxxxxx>
                    wrote:

                        Hi.

                        I'm passing on the information I have
                        regarding Melodyne's latest update.

                        My

                        initial thoughts were correct and Celemony
                        have moved to a different

                        graphics library, hence why Jaws can no longer
                        see any text on

                        screen at all. I'm not sure if this also has
                        an impact on other

                        solutions for Melodyne, but it's quite clear
                        that we're at the end

                        of the road with this product, unless Jaws
                        developers can address

                        it, or the graphics library in question can be
                        worked on with accessibility in mind.

                        Celemony tell me that the V5.1.1.003 version
                        will be available to

                        anyone who requests it from them, but it won't
                        be available via

                        their website. This is the last build that
                        text can be seen on

                        screen. The latest build

                        (V5.2.0.006) breaks the ability to read text
                        and they have no plans

                        to rectify this, as they are now sticking with
                        this new library,

                        which is called Skia.

                        They did say they would be willing to update
                        the version of Skia

                        they use, if any work with accessibility is
                        done, as it's open

                        source, so is available to people to work
                        with. Apparently, Skia is

                        backed by Google, so I would have thought that
                        accessibility should

                        be part of it's mandate to deliver that
                        accessibility, but this sort

                        of stuff is outside of my knowledge and I have
                        no contacts who know

                        about this sort of thing available at the moment.

                        I will try to contact dev's at FS or whatever
                        they're called now,

                        but again, I have no direct contacts there, so
                        I would have thought

                        it's going to be difficult to raise this
                        problem with the people who

                        need to know. If anyone thinks they have
                        something to offer with

                        making Skia support screen readers, or if
                        someone has a contact at

                        FS I can write to, then please get in touch:

                        Stevespamer68@xxxxxxxxx
                        <mailto:Stevespamer68@xxxxxxxxx
                        <mailto:Stevespamer68@xxxxxxxxx>>

                        Best steve.

                        Samplitude Access-The Gateway To Pro Recording
                        With Samplitude For

                        the Visually Impaired:
                         <http://www.samplitudeaccess.org.uk>

                        www.samplitudeaccess.org.uk
                        <http://www.samplitudeaccess.org.uk>

                        Follow me on Twitter:

                        stevesax123

                        Contact me:

                        Mobile:

                        +44 (0)7733373714

                        E-Mail:

                        stevespamer68@xxxxxxxxx

                    --

                    - To post to the mailing list, simply send email to

                    vipaudioaccess@xxxxxxxxxxxxx.

                    - To subscribe to the list, send an email to

                    vipaudioaccess-request@xxxxxxxxxxxxx

                    with 'subscribe' in the Subject field.

                    - To unsubscribe from the list, send an email to

                    vipaudioaccess-request@xxxxxxxxxxxxx

                    with 'unsubscribe' in the Subject field.

                    - For more list options, like setting digest and
                    vacation modes,

                    visit //www.freelists.org/list/vipaudioaccess

                    - Online, searchable archives of the list are
                    available at

                    //www.freelists.org/archive/vipaudioaccess

                    --

                    - To post to the mailing list, simply send email to

                    vipaudioaccess@xxxxxxxxxxxxx.

                    - To subscribe to the list, send an email to

                    vipaudioaccess-request@xxxxxxxxxxxxx

                    with 'subscribe' in the Subject field.

                    - To unsubscribe from the list, send an email to

                    vipaudioaccess-request@xxxxxxxxxxxxx

                    with 'unsubscribe' in the Subject field.

                    - For more list options, like setting digest and
                    vacation modes,

                    visit //www.freelists.org/list/vipaudioaccess

                    - Online, searchable archives of the list are
                    available at

                    //www.freelists.org/archive/vipaudioaccess

                --

                - To post to the mailing list, simply send email to
                vipaudioaccess@xxxxxxxxxxxxx.

                - To subscribe to the list, send an email to

                vipaudioaccess-request@xxxxxxxxxxxxx

                with 'subscribe' in the Subject field.

                - To unsubscribe from the list, send an email to

                vipaudioaccess-request@xxxxxxxxxxxxx

                with 'unsubscribe' in the Subject field.

                - For more list options, like setting digest and
                vacation modes, visit

                //www.freelists.org/list/vipaudioaccess

                - Online, searchable archives of the list are
                available at

                //www.freelists.org/archive/vipaudioaccess

                --

                - To post to the mailing list, simply send email to
                vipaudioaccess@xxxxxxxxxxxxx.

                - To subscribe to the list, send an email to

                vipaudioaccess-request@xxxxxxxxxxxxx

                with 'subscribe' in the Subject field.

                - To unsubscribe from the list, send an email to

                vipaudioaccess-request@xxxxxxxxxxxxx

                with 'unsubscribe' in the Subject field.

                - For more list options, like setting digest and
                vacation modes, visit

                //www.freelists.org/list/vipaudioaccess

                - Online, searchable archives of the list are
                available at

                //www.freelists.org/archive/vipaudioaccess

                --

                - To post to the mailing list, simply send email to
                vipaudioaccess@xxxxxxxxxxxxx.

                - To subscribe to the list, send an email to

                vipaudioaccess-request@xxxxxxxxxxxxx

                with 'subscribe' in the Subject field.

                - To unsubscribe from the list, send an email to

                vipaudioaccess-request@xxxxxxxxxxxxx

                with 'unsubscribe' in the Subject field.

                - For more list options, like setting digest and
                vacation modes, visit

                //www.freelists.org/list/vipaudioaccess

                - Online, searchable archives of the list are
                available at

                //www.freelists.org/archive/vipaudioaccess

                --

                - To post to the mailing list, simply send email to
                vipaudioaccess@xxxxxxxxxxxxx.

                - To subscribe to the list, send an email to

                vipaudioaccess-request@xxxxxxxxxxxxx

                with 'subscribe' in the Subject field.

                - To unsubscribe from the list, send an email to

                vipaudioaccess-request@xxxxxxxxxxxxx

                with 'unsubscribe' in the Subject field.

                - For more list options, like setting digest and
                vacation modes, visit

                //www.freelists.org/list/vipaudioaccess

                - Online, searchable archives of the list are
                available at

                //www.freelists.org/archive/vipaudioaccess

                --

                - To post to the mailing list, simply send email to
                vipaudioaccess@xxxxxxxxxxxxx.

                - To subscribe to the list, send an email to

                vipaudioaccess-request@xxxxxxxxxxxxx

                with 'subscribe' in the Subject field.

                - To unsubscribe from the list, send an email to

                vipaudioaccess-request@xxxxxxxxxxxxx

                with 'unsubscribe' in the Subject field.

                - For more list options, like setting digest and
                vacation modes, visit

                //www.freelists.org/list/vipaudioaccess

                - Online, searchable archives of the list are
                available at

                //www.freelists.org/archive/vipaudioaccess

            --
            - To post to the mailing list, simply send email to
            vipaudioaccess@xxxxxxxxxxxxx.

            - To subscribe to the list, send an email to
            vipaudioaccess-request@xxxxxxxxxxxxx
            with 'subscribe' in the Subject field.

            - To unsubscribe from the list, send an email to
            vipaudioaccess-request@xxxxxxxxxxxxx
            with 'unsubscribe' in the Subject field.

            - For more list options, like setting digest and vacation
            modes, visit
            //www.freelists.org/list/vipaudioaccess

            - Online, searchable archives of the list are available at
            //www.freelists.org/archive/vipaudioaccess

            --
            - To post to the mailing list, simply send email to
            vipaudioaccess@xxxxxxxxxxxxx.

            - To subscribe to the list, send an email to
            vipaudioaccess-request@xxxxxxxxxxxxx
            with 'subscribe' in the Subject field.

            - To unsubscribe from the list, send an email to
            vipaudioaccess-request@xxxxxxxxxxxxx
            with 'unsubscribe' in the Subject field.

            - For more list options, like setting digest and vacation
            modes, visit
            //www.freelists.org/list/vipaudioaccess

            - Online, searchable archives of the list are available at
            //www.freelists.org/archive/vipaudioaccess

Other related posts: