On Wed, 29 Oct 2008, Loretta Conaty wrote:
Perhaps some of ye would be kind enough to have a look at the below web site as it is going live on 10th November and the lady setting up this new business is very interested in making it accessible to the blind. It is quite a large site and she is sensitive to all disabilities and so would appreciate some feedback.
Hi Loretta - As has been already said, it is very welcome for any web site operators to pay attention to accessibility, and they should certainly be strongly encouraged for that. In terms of looking at the current site, a "proper" evaluation would, of course, take a fair amount of effort, so I have only been able to have a fairly cursory look; but on that basis, I would personally have to say there is certainly scope for significant improvement: - The styling does not adapt well to font size scaling. With moderate levels of font size increase, texts begin to overlap and/or spill into areas with poor contrast, making pages very difficult or impossible to read. - Some headings are being used to structure pages, which is a good sign; but they are not always used consistently or clearly. So, for example, on this page: <http://giftsandv.morsolutions.net/index/store-product?id=19> there is a completely empty H1 element (actually coming after several H2 elements) which definitely confuses my page outliner. - On that same page, which gives a sample from browsing the catalogue of products, there are many product images, all of which have alt attributes; which would normally be a great thing. Except that, in this case, the content of the alt attributes is simply repeating text that is already present in the normal content of the page. In that circumstance I would classify these images are "eye candy" and use null alt attributes instead. But there is a problem with that, because these images are hypertext linked, and we don't want links with no associated text, but that brings me to my next point ... - ... which is that there are a whole lot of links all with the same link text (namely, "VIEW PRODUCT DETAILS" - and yes, they are in all caps...). Now the targets of these links duplicate the targets of the linked images; but, at best, that is not at all obvious. The preferred mechanism would be to hypertext link the phrase describing each product instead ("Death by Chocolate", "New Home", etc.); but include the corresponding image (now with null alt text) in the scope of each link. Then there is only one link for each product, it already has the correct text, the images don't duplicate this text, and there are no links with duplicated link text. Win all round. - Another example page: <http://giftsandv.morsolutions.net/index/product/?id=847> This shows a form to actually fill in an order quantity and choose some options for the time. The form fields all have lables; and these labels have been marked up with the LABEL element; but they have not been linked (via the "for" attribute) to the respective fields. Again, just to emphasise, this is not a scientific or comprehensive review; it's just what I happened to notice on a quick look. But it does underline that, although web accessibility is not the proverbial "rocket science", it does require professional, technical, expertise and it does potentially require attention to a wide variety of details in site design. Unfortunately, with the best will in the world, it is not generally something that can be just "bolted on" shortly before a site launches. So it is absolutely great that this person or company is concerned about web accessibility, and I would strongly encourage them to take the next step, which is to ensure that there is proper professional support for it from whoever is actually designing or supporting the system. Best wishes, - Barry. -- Barry McMullin, Dublin City University phone: +353-1-700-5432 web: http://www.eeng.dcu.ie/~mcmullin/ =========================================================== The vicsireland mailing list To unsubscribe at any time send a mail to: vicsireland-request@xxxxxxxxxxxxxwith the word "unsubscribe", without the quotes in the subject of the message.
To contact the moderator send mail to: tim.j.culhane@xxxxxxxxx For mor information on the Visually Impaired Computer Society visit: http://www.vicsireland.org