At 04:25 PM 7/22/2011, Eric wrote:
Hi Bob- As you allude to, the labeling the correction from the rolleinar as parallax compensation is a misnomer. It is an attempt to correct for framing errors between viewing and taking lenses. But as you correctly state, the only way to compensate for the difference in perspective between taking and viewing lenses is to move the one to the position of the other. Generally this is not necessary when shooting at 3 meters or more, but I have experienced perspective problems using all three Rolleinars because of this inherent issue. The closer you shoot, the greater the chance perspective differences will cause problems. Eric Goldstein
Does anyone know what distance the prism is supposed to correct the framing precisely? I suppose one could work that out by taking the prism out and measuring the angle of deflection, and finding out how far out the offset equals the lens spacing. I haven't used a Rolleinar in a long time, and that was underwater, where lots of things differ from an air environment, including movement, etc. Perhaps it's sort of self-limiting in that with a close up lens in place, one can't focus at infinity, only out to some specific distance.