[nasional_list] [ppiindia] Cartoon battle turns uglier
- From: "Ambon" <sea@xxxxxxxxxx>
- To: <"Undisclosed-Recipient:;"@freelists.org>
- Date: Sun, 5 Feb 2006 22:55:45 +0100
** Forum Nasional Indonesia PPI India Mailing List **
** Untuk bergabung dg Milis Nasional kunjungi:
** Situs Milis: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/ppiindia/ **
** Beasiswa dalam negeri dan luar negeri S1 S2 S3 dan post-doctoral
scholarship, kunjungi
http://informasi-beasiswa.blogspot.com
**http://weekly.ahram.org.eg/2006/780/re32.htm
2 - 8 February 2006
Issue No. 780
Cartoon battle turns uglier
A Danish newspaper's apology failed to subdue the anger on the street over
cartoons depicting Prophet Mohamed. Gihan Shahine tracks a telling week
Many Muslims in Egypt and the Islamic world scoffed at the apology proffered by
Jyllands-Posten's Chief Editor Carsten Juste this week for the newspaper's
decision to publish 12 cartoons depicting Prophet Mohamed, including one with a
turban shaped like a bomb strapped to his head.
The cartoons appeared in the Danish newspaper on 30 September 2005. When
complaints first surfaced about them, Juste said he "would not dream of saying
sorry". This week's turnaround was the result of a sudden escalation of anger
in the Muslim world over the offensive cartoons, which were subsequently
republished in Norway.
The newspaper was apparently pressured into issuing the apology when Danish
businessmen expressed concerns over growing waves of boycotts of Danish
products across the Arab world. Negative diplomatic ramifications had also
started to appear. On Sunday Libya closed its embassy in Copenhagen in protest,
and threatened to take "unspecific economic measures" against Denmark, while
Saudi Arabia recalled its ambassador earlier in the week.
In response to calls by religious leaders, Danish products were boycotted en
masse in Saudi Arabia, several other Gulf countries, Yemen and Iran. Meanwhile,
a spate of protests erupted in different parts of the world. On the West Bank,
members of Fatah's Al-Aqsa Martyrs Brigades carried out a major protest, with
the demonstrators burning the Danish flag, and calling on Palestinian
authorities to cut diplomatic ties with Denmark. They also threatened Danes in
the area, and told them to leave immediately.
The Saudi Arabian boycott in particular hit Danish businesses hard, threatening
some 1.3 billion Saudi riyals worth of exports. Egypt joined the boycott fray
on Sunday, with many major supermarket chains, including Metro and Seoudi,
announcing that they had stopped selling Danish products. The Pharmacists'
Syndicate in Alexandria also decided to boycott Danish pharmaceutical
suppliers, and called upon the Egyptian government to recall its ambassador to
Denmark. Mobile messages calling for a boycott, and listing the Danish and
Norwegian products to be avoided were widely circulated.
"My 10-year-old son has now learnt to check the label of sweets before he buys
them to make sure they are not made in Denmark or Norway," said a 30-year-old
mother while shopping in a supermarket. "If Danes are free to insult our
prophet, then we are free not to buy their products."
The relativity of freedom appeared to be the key issue at stake. After all,
tellingly accompanying the newspaper's apology was a warning that "the
situation demands serious consideration by the EU, because crucial principles
are at stake if the situation is not tackled sensibly." The EU, for its part,
appeared to be supporting the Danish government when it declared that, "any
boycott of Danish goods would be seen as a boycott of European goods."
The conditional nature of these remarks helped keep the controversy alive. An
angry woman on an Orbit satellite channel talk show on Monday night seemed to
be speaking for many in the Arab world when she said that the newspaper's
"apology was far from enough". During the show, hundreds of people called in
and sent messages urging a continuation of the boycott. "The Danes, and their
government, insisted on insulting our prophet, and showed that they care little
for our feelings. Now they come to simply say 'sorry'. This is unacceptable,
and sorry: we don't need their products anymore," said another of the show's
guests.
The jab at the Danish government and public was in reaction to Danish Prime
Minister Anders Fogh Rasmussen's decision not to intervene in the affair, on
the grounds of freedom of expression. An opinion poll also showed that 79 per
cent of Danes thought Rasmussen should not issue an apology, and 62 per cent
said the newspaper should not apologise.
Rasmussen did say, however, that his government respects Islam, and never meant
to defame prophets. He also expressed hopes that the crisis would end after the
newspaper apologised for the offence.
That was not likely to happen, as was clear from the reaction of disgruntled
Egyptian MP Hamdi Hassan, who is also a member of the outlawed Muslim
Brotherhood. "The Danish government needs to make a more formal apology," he
told Al-Ahram Weekly, "in acknowledgment that freedom of expression does not
mean people are free to insult prophets."
Others slammed the EU's "double standards" for keeping silent about the
cartoons ridiculing Prophet Mohamed, while insisting on enforcing economic
sanctions against countries that publish anti-Semitic material. "The world
would have been up in arms had a Jewish sanctuary been defamed instead,"
thundered Ahmed, a 36-year-old accountant. "The world has to know Muslims will
defend their prophet until their last breath as well."
Abdel-Moeti Bayoumi, a member of Al-Azhar's Islamic Research Academy (IRA),
called the boycott a religious duty. "The boycott is the least Muslims could do
to defend their prophet after the majority of Danish people supported their
government for not apologising for the offensive drawings," Bayoumi told the
Weekly. "Now other nations will think twice before defaming Islam."
This also appeared to be a clear case of over-optimistic thinking. On
Wednesday, French newspaper France Soir decided to reproduce the offensive
cartoons. The decision was made, the paper said, to show that "religious dogma"
has no place in a secular society. The French government backed the paper's
stance, saying it supported press freedom, although it also added that beliefs
and religions must be respected. A domino effect soon took place, with several
other major European newspapers -- including Germany's Die Welt, Italy's La
Stampa, and Spain's El Periodico -- also choosing to reprint the offensive
cartoons.
"Muslims might have miscalculated the manner in which they handled the crisis,"
noted prominent Islamic scholar Abdel-Sabour Shahine, who suggested that
instead of pursuing a boycott of Danish products, the Islamic world should have
shown more tolerance, by focusing on promoting dialogue with the west, and
educating them more about Islam. "The Qur'an ordains Muslims to engage in
peaceful dialogue and use a more logical approach with those of different
creeds." The prophet himself, Shahine argued, was constantly subject to offence
during the first years of his prophecy in Mecca, and his reactions were so
tolerant that those who initially opposed him ended up becoming Muslim.
"After all," said Shahine, "we'd rather have the Danes apologising out of
conviction, rather than because they feel threatened."
Others, like Hassan, continued to insist that the boycott was very effective in
delivering an important message to the world: that Muslims are still "alive,
and are ready to unite and move".
The question of who might lead that movement, however, was still very much up
in the air. Many Egyptians were upset at what they called the "shamefully weak
stance" of Al-Azhar, the Sunni world's foremost seat of learning. Al-Azhar's
grand imam, often criticised for toeing the government line, had not been one
of the first to speak up about the offensive cartoons. When he finally did, he
sparked public outrage when he based his denunciation on the grounds that it is
"not acceptable to ridicule dead people in general, and deceased prophets in
particular"-- a statement that, albeit bearing the official seal of Al-Azhar,
was heartily denied in a subsequent statement issued by Al-Azhar's Islamic
Research Academy (IRA) on Wednesday.
Senior Al-Azhar cleric Mahmoud Ashour said that Al-Azhar scholars convened
immediately after the publication of the offensive cartoons to study ways of
countering them. "Our response appeared to be late because we had to first see
how the Danish government would react," Ashour said. "But the press spares no
effort in belittling the role of the grand imam, who loves Islam and the
prophet more than anyone else."
Hassan and others remained sceptical of these kinds of claims. "The grand
imam's response sounded even more offensive than the cartoons themselves
because it supposedly came from the most prestigious seat of learning in the
Islamic world," the MP said.
"How can Prophet Mohamed be compared with any other dead person?" asked Ibrahim
El-Zaafarani, a Muslim Brotherhood member of the Shura Council who also serves
as secretary-general of Alexandria's Doctors' Syndicate. "It's a shame, a
shame."
Other scholars argued that the imam's statement ran counter to a principle
enshrined in the Qur'an, which implies that Prophet Mohamed is spiritually
alive amongst Muslims via his teachings. "If the grand imam is more interested
in his [position]," El-Zaafarani said, "he needs to be made aware that the
prestige of his seat stems from the grandiosity of his religion."
In the meantime, a host of other organisations -- including the outlawed Muslim
Brotherhood, the Federation of Arab Journalists, the International Union of
Muslim Clergy, the Islamic Conference Organisation, the Arab League, and the
Egyptian Parliament -- all joined the fray, issuing statements condemning the
cartoons. Several protest marches are also being planned for Cairo and
Alexandria this Friday
[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
***************************************************************************
Berdikusi dg Santun & Elegan, dg Semangat Persahabatan. Menuju Indonesia yg
Lebih Baik, in Commonality & Shared Destiny.
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/ppiindia
***************************************************************************
__________________________________________________________________________
Mohon Perhatian:
1. Harap tdk. memposting/reply yg menyinggung SARA (kecuali sbg otokritik)
2. Pesan yg akan direply harap dihapus, kecuali yg akan dikomentari.
3. Reading only, http://dear.to/ppi
4. Satu email perhari: ppiindia-digest@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
5. No-email/web only: ppiindia-nomail@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
6. kembali menerima email: ppiindia-normal@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Yahoo! Groups Links
<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/ppiindia/
<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
ppiindia-unsubscribe@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/
** Forum Nasional Indonesia PPI India Mailing List **
** Untuk bergabung dg Milis Nasional kunjungi:
** Situs Milis: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/ppiindia/ **
** Beasiswa dalam negeri dan luar negeri S1 S2 S3 dan post-doctoral
scholarship, kunjungi
http://informasi-beasiswa.blogspot.com **
Other related posts:
- » [nasional_list] [ppiindia] Cartoon battle turns uglier
