Sorry if this exceeds my third, but I couldn't contribute any yesterday and the mail accumulated. I loved this reflection by Geary and may get back to it in due time. Mainly for him to tell me what he meant by 'crock'. Cfr. 'hoot'. 'hootnanny'. "I don't give a hoot what the dictionary says" (Grice), "And that's where you make your big mistake". Did Austin mean that Grice should give a hoot? Language _is_ a crock, or would be a crock without Grice who implicated it all masterly. There was once an Oxonian called Grice Who believed that all words had their price. If it's not the explicature, Then it's just the implicature Said this clever Oxonian called Grice. JLS In a message dated 1/14/2010 4:02:26 P.M. Eastern Standard Time, atlas@xxxxxxxxxxxxx writes: If you haven't got a nickel to your name. but you've got a dime and fifty billion dollars, you still don't have a nickel to your name, ergo, language is a crock. Mike Geary not taking any logical nickels in Memphis