There is a coincidence between Bernays and Grice which is non-existent between Bernays and Popper. Bernays, like Grice, were born in England. This from: http://daniestrauss.com/2003%20Rationality.pdf "It is significant that Paul Bernays, the co-worker of the foremost mathematician of the 20th century, David Hilbert, in his contribution to the Festschrift of Karl Popper remarks that any account of rationality has to pay attention to concept-formation. He states that the “proper characteristic of rationality” is “to be found in the conceptual element” (1974: 601)." Grice, an Englishman, like Bernays, would agree. "We have followed up the suggestion made by Bernays, namely that the meaning of rationality ought to be related to the nature, scope and limits of concept-formation and we have done that by highlighting the restrictive and expansive boundaries of rationality. But what is the status of the “in-between,” of the intrinsic domain of rationality, the domain of logicality?" Grice, like Bernays, an Englishman, would agree. Cheers, Speranza ------------------------------------------------------------------ To change your Lit-Ideas settings (subscribe/unsub, vacation on/off, digest on/off), visit www.andreas.com/faq-lit-ideas.html