[LRFlex] Leica vs. Canon

  • From: "Dr. Puritz" <drpuritz@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>
  • To: <leicareflex@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>
  • Date: Tue, 19 Oct 2004 17:56:00 -0400

I have noted with some surprise the incredible price for the new Leica 28-90 Asph zoom lens ($3295.00 ). Today I had the opportunity to hold and examine several models from the Canon Eos line with one of their 70-200/2.8 image stabilizing pro lenses, and a few of their wide angle zoom pro lenses, one about equal to the Leica lens above. Interesting to note that the Eos1V WITH the telephoto pro-lens noted above costs about the same as the Leica lens alone, and SEVERAL of the wide angle zoom lenses and the camera body would cost LESS then the leica lens noted above. If one went "down "just a slight bit to the Eos model under the 1V ( according to the pro here about the same without a few of the probably unnecessary bells and whistles ), then one might be able to get the body, the pro telephoto lens, the battery back with winder, and several of their pro quality image stabilized wide angle lenses ( 2.8 ) for about the same price ( give and take a few bucks ) as that one Leica lens. Yup....a professional quality camera, and 3 image stabilized lenses with winder, lenses are top of the Canon line, for just a slight bit more then the price of that one Leica lens that has focal lengths that are not at all esoteric.

I ask that the Leica lovers ( and I am certainly one with a VERY extensive and complete investment in both M and R gear of all kinds...bodies and lenses, accessories, etc. ) not get too excited when I ask what the deuce is going on? The Canon AF Eos is nice. OK....the viewfinder is perhaps just smidgeon less bright then the R8 and R9....but the AF is quick and quiet, the body is substantial, etc., etc. One can purchase a Canon digital camera body and use all of the lenses noted above... cost is a LOT less then the R digital module that will be here very shortly. Indeed, one might have almost $4,000 bucks left over for several vacations at which to use the cameras.

I realize none of us has a ready reply, and we are biased towards Leica glass and "quality"....and most of us are not going to dump our beloved Leica gear for Canon...but I must admit to wondering, " What is Leica really thinking"? They must sell everything they make to a small devoted group of Leicaphiles who will ante up the $5,000 for the digital module....but geesh, why can't we have a zoom lens, 28-90, for something aproaching a realistic price?

Elliot who will continue to use the R8 and R9, but will continue to wonder....

------
Unsubscribe or change to/from Digest Mode at:
   www.horizon.bc.ca/~dnr/lrflex.htm
Archives are at:
   www.freelists.org/archives/leicareflex/

Other related posts: