Hi, >>Here is my suggestion: >>Have only the members of the community who have experience with at least >>FOUR of the following: (I only fit the top three) >>- Windows Update and Install/Uninstall programs >>- Software Valet >>- Linux package managers >>- QNX's package manager >>- Mac install/uninstall procedures >>Identify themselves and form a subcommittee and conduct a separate >>concentrated discussion. Then have them submit sketch designs and specs >>to the general OBOS community in no more than two weeks. (If not two >>weeks, then set another deadline. I think a deadline would be important >>to keep things moving.) > >Sounds reasonable. Anyone up for this? Even if there were a couple of people >with experience with all of these, total (someone with Win/Linux, someone with >QNX/Mac), that would be great! As long as you don't request me to get too deeply into that (already have something cooking with another team ^_^) I am willing to help discussing those issues. I have experience with the BeOS, QNX, Linux, FreeBSD & Windows installation things as a user, plus I have experience as a developer with Software Valet (for distributing "OpenTracker.fr" for example) and InstallShield. As far as I'm concerned I find the BSD and QNX ones very powerful. I believe Software Valet is a very good product too that should be used more ^_^ It provides some interesting flexibility. However IMHO it has no clue about what a dependency might be and also lacks some scripting (I don't mean including scripts in packages but being able to command package building through scripts) :o) Would also be nice to make sure the package file is "garbage-proof" when moved through different filesystems. I hate the "seems the endlines are bad in this file" error or whatever looked like it when downloading a pkg to a FAT FS. Jean