On 04/05/2012 11:05, Stephan Aßmus wrote: > For the future, I think the menu should not directly be editable by the > user. I think users only spent time on this if there is a need. On BeOS, > I have indeed messed with the DeskBar menu, I think I've replaced the > "Applications" folder with a link to where I actually installed > Applications, and thus I always had access to whatever I installed, > without ever updating the menu again. On Linux, I have never seen the > need to mess with the menu. Mostly because a) what I install shows up, > and b) I could agree with the sorting and categories. Except with Terminal which is anything but an "accessory" to me :D > > So ideally, I think the Deskbar menu should be dynamic based on a Query > for all applications. Apps would have an attribute "META:category" or > similar (could be fully integrated with FileTypes and the Locale Kit, > just like the name is now). This would be a comma separated list of > categories, where this app can appear. This would even make an app > appear in multiple places in the Deskbar menu hierarchy, which makes it > easier for users to find it, should they have different expectations or > assumptions of the category. And then Deskbar would of course build the > menu based on merging all categories found in all applications. It > wouldn't know any "default" categories. I recall trying this with hardcoded queries long ago, worked not too bad: http://revolf.free.fr/beos/shots/shot_query_based_menu.png François.