[geocentrism] Re: For Robert Bennett and stella parallax
- From: Allen Daves <allendaves@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
- To: geocentrism@xxxxxxxxxxxxx
- Date: Fri, 23 May 2008 10:21:47 -0700 (PDT)
Regner stated: But if all the stars, and with them, all the galaxies,
are centered on the Sun, what then is centered on the Earth, justifying the
label of "Geocentric Universe"???
I agree in principle with the essence of that question, that is exactly why I
have never liked that idea ( although that does not mean it is not posible)
....however......If the stars are centered on the Earth, there would be no
parallax. I believe we agree on that, correct? To know and or claim that
parallax is proof for the proper motions when the proper motions of the stars
themselves must be assumed to make any such deductions .....is the very
question under consideration!?......that is not just presumptuous but So if the
observations of sun planet and stars timing is not observed as perfectly
consistent ..............ummmm............again you must demonstrate the
observation that shows it is just an illusion first before you assume it is
just an illusion that then can be used to interpret the observations from.....!
It amazes me you cant see your own inconsistencies in both your methods used to
frame your arguments as well as the substance of your
arguments themselves.... .... ..well silly.... Your statment would only be
true if and only if you first assume that the sun & or back ground stars have
no other intrinsic or distinguishable proper motions external of a smooth
consent velocities in orbit or in a rotating universe...and why would
it?!....any given rotating mass has intrinsic vibrations and uncertainties to
it no matter how "balanced" it is,......... in fact you can't have any motion
without vibrations.......ummm.........worse assume that the sun has no other
intrinsic orbital variations it is timing.......Now that it quite a
presumption..because the sun and moon are erratic and never ever have perfectly
identical circuit times....hence the use of atomic clocks rather then just
timing the good olʼ sun& moon.........ummmm......
Other related posts:
