I found an old Seybold Report with the title "Measuring the quality of ICC profiles" http://www.heidelberg.com/wwwbinaries/bin/files/dotcom/en/prinect/prinect_profile_toolbox.pdf . On monitor profiles they have three objective test for the quality. The are, page 13, archived gamma, DE difference in whitepoint from target D50 and the last one average DE for a colorcheker measured on monitor. I tried to do the last step. I found a digital LAB version of the colorchecker http://www.colorremedies.com/realworldcolor/downloads/Macbeth_ColorChecker_LAB.tif.zip I fixed? (added a white patch nr 25) to the colorcheker.ti2 in the ref directory(attached), and measured the colorchecker when I viewed it with cinepaint with colormanagment on. I then measured it with "chartread -d -H ColorChecker" with my eye-one pro. When I afterwards did a "profile -v -as Colorcheker" I get an avg DE on 5.6. I get some real big mismatch on a few of the patches (set profcheck output) There is DE of 60 on patch 16. I guess this yellow patch is out of gamut. I find it hard to understand why they have included out of gamut measurements. I also get a quit big error on patch 20( its L*81) with a DE of about 18. I don't understand why since I get pretty nice numbers when I did the calibration with dispcal. I have attached a log for my calibration/profiling today. Do you think this is something similar to what they have done in the Seybold Report? I don't expect that I should match those numbers since I have a pretty old monitor, but it's always fun to experiment a little and maybe learn something. Lars Tore Gustavsen
DE Patch 0.434580 8 0.560124 22 0.608833 21 0.618981 24 1.070394 13 1.160494 4 1.267156 2 1.344788 5 1.578218 11 1.871612 3 1.872423 18 2.014564 1 2.065875 23 2.212793 10 2.648374 14 2.901850 9 3.749590 25 4.027044 17 4.681445 15 5.525888 6 6.098186 19 6.916798 12 7.878428 7 17.966567 20 59.859779 16
Matrix = 0.428105 0.289633 0.134801 0.232963 0.657081 0.065105 0.012379 0.081610 0.600622 Offset = -0.019995 0.006099 -0.078470 0 harmonics = 2.022386 2.215874 3.186807 1 harmonics = 0.284609 0.031071 -0.799580 2 harmonics = -0.241875 0.158033 -2.099517 3 harmonics = 0.161734 -0.497972 1.131950 4 harmonics = -0.102582 0.273724 -0.173979 5 harmonics = -0.019623 0.091990 -0.847132 6 harmonics = -0.019853 -0.381095 -0.224354 7 harmonics = 0.010040 0.032083 0.291994 8 harmonics = -0.065277 0.264820 0.190591 9 harmonics = 0.015681 -0.120464 -0.642684 Find white & black points White point = 0.852539 0.955149 0.694612 Black point = 0.001767 0.004008 0.000498 White point XYZ = 0.852539 0.955149 0.694612 Black point XYZ = 0.001767 0.004008 0.000498 Fixup matrix for white point After white point adjust: Matrix = 0.472461 0.333220 0.158519 0.252240 0.674857 0.072903 0.014574 0.090830 0.719496 Done gama/shaper and matrix creation Profile done profile check complete, peak err = 59.859779, avg err = 5.637391
Matrix = 0.444118 0.322434 0.122681 0.249509 0.646798 0.089312 0.004784 0.105506 0.629647 Offset = 0.004658 0.004922 0.004948 0 harmonics = 2.235037 2.187631 2.240639 1 harmonics = -0.060557 0.009011 -0.051760 2 harmonics = -0.070965 -0.068296 -0.064065 3 harmonics = -0.029771 -0.017513 -0.028094 4 harmonics = -0.005864 -0.044992 -0.044253 5 harmonics = 0.005867 -0.007206 0.010208 6 harmonics = -0.029305 -0.017600 -0.047362 7 harmonics = -0.022299 -0.032295 -0.030591 8 harmonics = -0.037681 -0.050462 -0.038819 9 harmonics = -0.035846 -0.058410 -0.047354 Find white & black points White point = 0.889233 0.985619 0.739936 Black point = 0.004263 0.004788 0.003657 White point XYZ = 0.889233 0.985619 0.739936 Black point XYZ = 0.004263 0.004788 0.003657 Fixup matrix for white point After white point adjust: Matrix = 0.472454 0.354112 0.137633 0.260412 0.646707 0.092882 0.005048 0.113460 0.706392 Done gama/shaper and matrix creation Profile done profile check complete, peak err = 4.776828, avg err = 1.030138
Setting up the instrument Instrument Type: Eye-One Pro Serial Number: 306673 Firmware version: 502 CPLD version: 999 Date manufactured: 16-2-2007 U.V. filter ?: No Measure Ambient ?: Yes Tot. Measurement Count: 1386 Remission Spot Count: 84 Remission Scan Count: 171 Date of last Remission spot cal: Mon Jan 21 18:39:15 2008 Remission Spot Count at last cal: 79 Total lamp usage: 727.580078 Place the instrument on its reflective white reference Serial no. 306673, and then hit any key to continue, or hit Esc, ^C or Q to abort: Calibration complete Place instrument on test window. Hit Esc, ^C or Q to give up, any other key to continue: Target white = native white point Target brightness = native brightness Target gamma = 2.200000 Commencing device calibration patch 6 of 6 Black = XYZ 0.31 0.28 0.28 Red = XYZ 50.29 27.87 0.64 Green = XYZ 37.68 74.68 11.15 Blue = XYZ 13.49 10.89 69.95 White = XYZ 101.50 113.53 81.91 patch 80 of 80 Initial native brightness target = 113.528561 cd/m^2 Target white value is XYZ 101.502137 113.528561 81.913943 Adjusted target black XYZ 0.24 0.27 0.20, Lab 2.16 0.00 0.00 Target black after min adjust: XYZ 0.34 0.38 0.27, Lab 3.03 -0.00 0.00 Current gamma curve offset = 0.111086, Gamma curve power = 2.594250 Total Iteration 4, Final Samples = 96 Final Repeat threshold = 0.500000 Creating initial calibration curves... Doing iteration 1 with 12 sample points and repeat threshold of 4.000000 DE patch 12 of 12 Brightness error = 0.000000 cd/m^2 White point error = 0.000000 deltaE Maximum neutral error (@ 0.875085) = 3.769726 deltaE Average neutral error = 2.431266 deltaE Computing update to calibration curves... Doing iteration 2 with 24 sample points and repeat threshold of 2.000000 DE patch 24 of 24 Brightness error = 0.000000 cd/m^2 White point error = 0.000000 deltaE Maximum neutral error (@ 0.227985) = 1.995954 deltaE Average neutral error = 1.037829 deltaE Computing update to calibration curves... Doing iteration 3 with 48 sample points and repeat threshold of 1.000000 DE patch 48 of 48 Brightness error = 0.000000 cd/m^2 White point error = 0.000000 deltaE Maximum neutral error (@ 0.000000) = 1.523348 deltaE Average neutral error = 0.580272 deltaE Computing update to calibration curves... Doing iteration 4 with 96 sample points and repeat threshold of 0.500000 DE patch 96 of 96 Brightness error = 0.000000 cd/m^2 White point error = 0.000000 deltaE Maximum neutral error (@ 0.000000) = 1.365594 deltaE Average neutral error = 0.359014 deltaE The instrument can be removed from the screen. Written calibration file 'TargetA.cal'
Calibration complete Place instrument on test window. Hit Esc, ^C or Q to give up, any other key to continue: Current calibration response: Black level = 0.37 cd/m^2 White level = 111.13 cd/m^2 Aprox. gamma = 2.13 Contrast ratio = 299:1 White chromaticity coordinates 0.3426, 0.3792 White Correlated Color Temperature = 5164K, DE to locus = 15.3 White Correlated Daylight Temperature = 5171K, DE to locus = 13.0 White Visual Color Temperature = 4764K, DE to locus = 14.9 White Visual Daylight Temperature = 4866K, DE to locus = 12.6 The instrument can be removed from the screen.