Marco, as i remember I was behind you and thinking you would have to tack for the land I asked ant for room for land but you got a good windshift and as you turned to port i tacked but ant did not, i was mistaken but I believe in real sailing you must give room when asked to and protest if it is not valid, i think we are probably bith a bit wrong but I am not totally sure. Maybe to just watch the replay you would say I am wrong but that is ok i apologise to Ant. Cheers, John. --- On Fri, 4/6/10, Piaggio, Marco <marco.piaggio@xxxxxx> wrote: From: Piaggio, Marco <marco.piaggio@xxxxxx> Subject: [acc_tr_vsk] Incident Antonio John Rick To: "acc_tr_vsk@xxxxxxxxxxxxx" <acc_tr_vsk@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> Date: Friday, 4 June, 2010, 8:40 I send you the replay. Mmmm Not easy to say for me .. Tell me! Marco