Re: [Wittrs] New Book on Wittgenstein and Constitutional Theory

Hi Sean

Thanks for your kind words. To me it works the other way around. Most of
the things you write contain very interesting material.

I am also not sure. Perhaps I read it in the Blue Book. I thought
Wittgenstein somewhere wrote on 'making the rules while playing the game'.
Hence, not following a rule but making one whie playing.

It is in the nature of a (language) game to have rules. But when one starts
-when is that?- there might be no rules -or a set of rules from another
game-. The game grows and the rules grow with them.

E.g. I do enjoy and deeply respect physics. I am proud to be able to
contribute. However, why is mathematics so succesful in explaining physical
phenomena? I think Wigner also asked this question.

A Wittgensteinian answer *could* be that the (science) game grew over the
years and the rules (mathematics) grew with it.

Of course we could also think that nature has a mathematical structure but
is that a fact? How can we know that?


On 18 September 2012 20:56, Sean Wilson <whoooo26505@xxxxxxxxx> wrote:

> Hi Han.
> Good to hear from you, as always.
> I'm not sure what you mean by "making the rules as we go up."  My book
> applies a wide array of Wittgenstein's ideas to the question of what a
> constitution means. I rely upon his views on language meaning, artisan
> judgments ("aesthetics"), aspect seeing, imponderable evidence, private
> language and assertability conditions (grammar). I don't think I have one
> of the so called "rule following passages" of Philosophical Investigations
> cited, but I could be wrong about that. I do, however, have what I have
> always considered to be a very important chapter in the book -- Chapter 2
> -- on how to follow a flexible rule. Based on the private feedback I've
> received on the book, however, people are not high on that chapter. I
> really like it because I think it clarifies the way both Dworkin and
> political scientists think about how this kind of statement can be
> "followed:" No State Shall Deny Equal Protection to its citizens.
> Anyway, always glad to see that you'd find anything I write to be even
> close to interesting, even as a topic.
> Regards and thanks.
> Dr. Sean Wilson, Esq.
> Assistant Professor
> Wright State University
> Personal Website:
> My New Book:
> _______________________________________________
> Wittrs mailing list
> Wittrs@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
Wittrs mailing list

Other related posts: