Noel, I couldn't agree more. While I choose to play a *LOT* of Bach and love to play the tracker instruments voiced for this music, I could not begin to imagine playing a baroque tracker for normal services in the type of architecture that is common to many (most?) American sanctuaries. I have only had the privilege of playing on two A/S instruments (opus 1301 and 1381), one sadly now unavailable (1301), but what an experience. Also have heard many live in concert. These instruments possess remarkable power and versatility, as well as some of the most beautiful voicings I can imagine. I remember almost being brought to tears when I heard that they had closed their doors. Scott -------------------------------------------------------- noel jones wrote: > Ralph, > > To get this rolling, the Aeolian Skinner Organ, considered by many to be the > finest example of this sort of organ building, is overwhelming chosen by > organists in blind testing, as their dream organ. > > Organ builders tend to act as if that is not true, but it is easy to tear > down > an icon, because it is so visible. > > I have had the opportunity to play A/S's in New York City and even in tiny > Oil > City, Pennsylvania (the church did have an oil well pumping in it church > yard...maybe that's how they were able to afford it). > > Grand Instruments! > > Soon to be published for the Rodgers Organ: Sommer Sonaten für Orgel - Summer Sonatas for Organ and MIDI Orchestra! - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - To unsubscribe or change mail delivery (digest, vacation) go to www.frogmusic.com/rodgersmem.html