[opendtv] Re: NBC Launching Live Stream | Multichannel

  • From: Craig Birkmaier <craig@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>
  • To: "opendtv@xxxxxxxxxxxxx" <opendtv@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>
  • Date: Fri, 19 Dec 2014 08:53:11 -0500

> I wrote:
> 
>> So Bert, do you expect more people to use the NBC authenticated TVE
>> services, or to pay CBS $5.99/mo for All Access?
> 
> More illustration of Craig's mindset. Examples are many, but this does remind 
> me of the early days of widescreen TVs and LCD TVs. Craig was assuring us 
> that costs of widescreen TVs would be too high for them to ever become 
> prevalent, and also that TV manufacturers would "never allow" HDTV sets to 
> become a commodity item. Why would they, Craig wondered. I remember 
> specifically informing Craig that not only will widescreen HDTVs dominate the 
> TV market, but that they would also dominate the PC monitor market.
> 
You are hopeless. Why answer the question when you can distort things I said 
almost two decades ago.

> I have no doubt that now, Craig will go on at length to explain why this 
> happened. And yet, at the time, he was as stubborn as he is now about 
> Internet TV over neutral pipes. The point is, it was obvious back then that 
> this was happening, just as this Internet TV transition is obvious now.

I have no doubt that you refuse to answer the question because the answer is so 
obvious, and it undermines your theories that the Internet will kill bundles.

> Of course they do, Craig. And the congloms and content owners are already 
> making that content openly available for anyone using one, or sometimes 
> several, optional standards. The receiver makers have only to comply.

Not true. They need a license from the content owners.
> 
> 
> Hey Craig. As far as I know, Dell did not have to get in bed with Netflix, to 
> allow Dell PCs to subscribe to Netflix.

Nor did Apple or Google or Amazon. Netflix is a SVOD Service - I.e. It requires 
a subscription. They actively sought out everyone that can host an App/player 
to sell subscriptions.

> If there was ANY special arrangement, it was the generic one applicable to 
> *all* PC makers, that HD content can only be sent to a monitor through HDMI.

You can thank Microsoft for this, as they agreed to cripple PCs to provide the 
content protection the content owners demanded. I'm not saying this was a bad 
thing for you, but it has no bearing on other platforms, as the content owners 
decide what they will allow where, and for how much.

Regards
Craig

Other related posts: