In a message dated 8/6/2004 11:46:15 PM Eastern Standard Time, Jlsperanza writes: > > "The demonstrable correlation of opposites is an image of the > > transcendental > > correlation of contradictories." E. Holder writes: >I was totally thinking the same thing. >What Weil must have in mind is >Aristotle's Square of Opposition. >It's the Square-of-Opposition-thing. Note that Weil seems to be suggesting that 'opposites' are images of 'contradictories'. In traditional logical terminology, you can have your cake (and eat it) -- there is such a thing as a 'contradictory opposition', as opposed to other types (notably contrary, subcontrary, and subaltern) opposition. It's all in the Square, of course. Cheers, JL "Opposition". OED Logic. The relation between two propositions which have the same subject and predicate but differ in quantity or quality, or both. For contradictory, contrary, subcontrary, and subaltern opposition, see the first terms. 1599 T. BLUNDEVILLE Art of Logicke 67 (heading) Of the opposition of Modals. 1697 tr. F. Burgersdijck Monitio Logica I. xxxiii. 128 True Opposition afore-mentioned is either Contrariety or Contradiction. 1788 T Reid Aristotle's Logic i. §3. 11 The four kinds of opposition of terms are explained. 1813-21 J. Bentham Fragm. Ontol. in Wks. (1843) VIII. 203 Subalternation, viz. logical subalternation, opposition, and connexion, or the relation between cause and effect. 1860 ABP. W. THOMSON Outl. Laws of Thought (ed. 5) 148 Opposition of Judgments is the relation between any two which have the same matter, but a different form. 1896 J. G. HIBBEN Logic (1905) xv. 128 In the discussion concerning the opposition of propositions, it was seen that the truth of the particular does not imply the truth of the universal. 1962 W. KNEALE & M. KNEALE Devel. Logic (1984) iv. 182 Galen assumes that disjunctive statements should, properly speaking, involve complete opposition of the disjuncts. 1993 A. BROADIE Introd. Medieval Logic vii. 129 Propositions related by opposition or equipollence have the same categorematic terms in the same order. ------------------------------------------------------------------ To change your Lit-Ideas settings (subscribe/unsub, vacation on/off, digest on/off), visit www.andreas.com/faq-lit-ideas.html