Le lundi, 3 mai 2004, =E0 22:03 Europe/Paris, andy amago a =E9crit : > The book I am referring to is, Mexifornia: A State of Becoming, by=20 > Victor Davis Hanson. > > > > > -----Forwarded Message----- > From: andy amago <aamago@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> > Sent: May 2, 2004 7:38 PM > To: lit-ideas@xxxxxxxxxxxxx, lit-ideas@xxxxxxxxxxxxx > Subject: Re: [lit-ideas] Long Live the Evolution > > America the Melting Pot requires at least one ethnic response. I=20 > wonder how people feel about the Balkanization of the United States=20 > into XXXXX-Americans. M.C. Don't see anything wrong with it. > Students less often answer questions with "I feel" and more often=20 > with, among others, "As a Latino-American I feel". M.C. So? > Many American-born Hispanics (we'll pick on them because they are the=20= > most numerous) dream of going back to an idealized Mexico, M.C. Seems like the most natural desire in the world. > the same Mexico that would give them a far inferior way of life. M.C. You know this for a fact, do you? Does *every* Mexican living in=20 Mexico have a life inferior to that of *every* Mexican living north of=20= the border? I kinda doubt it. > Likewise Chinese and all nationalities who have their feet planted=20= > here while their hearts are elsewhere. M.C. "Nationalities" have neither feet nor hearts. People do. Where=20 peoples' feet are is easy enough to observe, measure and quantify.=20 Where their hearts are is (a) impossible for you to know and (b) none=20 of your beeswax. > Most menus require a second language, M.C. Quelle horreur=A0! I can't believe that such barbarism is allowed=20= within a nation so great as the USA! Excuse me, the shock is too great,=20= I must go and lie down. > and even the local Social Security offices "speak your language", by=20= > the dozens. Seems a schizy way to live, not just for the country but=20= > for the individuals with joint loyalties as well. M.C. It might be interesting to examine the presuppositions underlying=20= this way of viewing things: a nation's inhabitants should have only=20 one loyalty: their hearts and souls should be utterly and inalienably=20 devoted to the Fatherland. Sounds to me like an ideology of which=20 Goebbels would heartily approve. At the risk of being declared a rootless, parasitic = intellectual, I=20 will nevertheless declare my preference - by a country mile- for the=20 richness of multiculturalism. While less comfortingly secure than=20 jingoistic fascism, it can open our eyes to the infinite wealth of=20 every culture, every one of which has precious wisdom to contribute.=20 Nationalism of the kind illustrated above is just a hypertrophied=20 version of individual egotism, and is just as puerile and stupid: it=20 appeals to humanity's basest instincts. Hence its popularity,=20 especially amoing the ignorant. All best wishes, Mike. > > > > Michael Chase=09 (goya@xxxxxxxxxxx) CNRS UPR 76/ l'Annee Philologique Villejuif-Paris France ------------------------------------------------------------------ To change your Lit-Ideas settings (subscribe/unsub, vacation on/off, digest on/off), visit www.andreas.com/faq-lit-ideas.html