Content-Type: text/plain; charset="us-ascii" Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit For me, it's not about whether the HOTS methodology is good or bad, it's about whether the imposition of the program, or any program for that matter, will advance or retard what I think should be the goals of a decent system of education. Here's one set I concocted: Educational Mission Statement In order to secure the future growth and prosperity of the people of Israel, the Ministry of Education guarantees a safe and healthy environment in which every child can realize his fullest potential as a student and as a human being. The Ministry's mission is to foster excellence and apply the best known educational practices to make of Israel's students: I. Moral and Ethical Human Beings, people who love life and who care for their fellow human beings and the society to which they belong; II. Active and Committed Citizens, people who understand Israel's history and are willing to take a stand for what they believe is right, for themselves, for their families and communities, and for society as a whole; III. Risk Takers, people who continuously challenge themselves, who set for themselves the highest of standards and strive to realize them; IV. Scientists and Philosophers, people who are intellectually curious, who delve deeply into matters, who constantly reflect, evaluate, and incorporate new information in their life-long quest to understand their world and how it works; and V. Individuals, people who are independent, proud, confident, and know what they stand for, while also accepting, respecting and relating with those who don't share their ideas and viewpoints. When we start spending too much time worrying about how to jump through the ministry hoops, and our own convictions and history are thrown to the side, it is no surprise how poor the engagement under or with an imposed program can be. What a relief if the ministry could just let teachers teach, but it can't because then there wouldn't be any work for the bureaucrats. David R. Herz <mailto:mr@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> teacher@xxxxxxxxxxxxx Skype: drherz Twitter: @drherz +972-4-641-8708 +972-58-606-5055 +203-517-0518 ************************************** ** Join ETNI on Facebook https://www.facebook.com/groups/31737970668/ ** ETNI Blog and Poll http://ask-etni.blogspot.co.il/ ** Etni homepage - http://www.etni.org ** post to ETNI List - etni@xxxxxxxxxxxxx ** help - ask@xxxxxxxx ***************************************