From: Judy Schermer Sent: Thursday, January 15, 2009 9:16 AM To: 'Maduffy@xxxxxxx' Subject: RE: [visionrehabtherapist] What do you think about the new ACVREP Certification requiremetns? Hi Maureen, I also have been closely following the discussion on the provisional certification. I think some of the problem with VRT is it's history. Since it was basically home-based, on the job training for it in the past (prior to the 60's), it is difficult to separate the historical background of it from the direction we'd like it to go now. The O&M history is different. However, just because our history was that doesn't mean we can't adhere to strict requirements for VRT certification now. I strongly oppose the provisional certification for VRTs and agree with much of the emails that have been sent over the past 2 weeks. Everyone recognizes and agrees that there is a shortage in the field. Some of the problem with "marketing" our field is the low pay. If we lower our standards to allow unqualified people to be certified, we MAY help it in the short run but we are destroying our field/profession in the long run. (not to mention the certified VRT, OM, and LVT who may decide that certification is not necessary/valued if the provisional track is allowed, and not get certified). My concern with the provisional certification and the assistant programs is it puts the stamp of approval on less qualified people to do our jobs. When you have employers (including directors of vision rehab. agencies) who do not really know what we do, why would they pay $30,000-$40,000 (still low) for a university trained, certified VRT when they can pay $20,000 for someone who has a provisional certification or was trained as an assistant. This is a real problem currently for our profession, even though I know that there are some VRTs out there who are supportive of the assistant program. To be fair, the VRT assistant is supposed to be working under the direct supervision of a certified VRT but, from personal experience, I know that this is not how it works in reality. Unfortunately, many agency directors, for whatever reason, seem to be ok with hiring these less qualified people with no certified VRT on staff to supervise. I don't have the answers and do appreciate the work the other professionals, AER, and ACVREP are trying to do in order to increase the number of people in the field. However, lowering our standards will also lower our credibility and value in the field which in turn will not increase the pay (through Medicare, etc...) which will affect the number of potential people going in the universities. It is a vicious cycle but we need to start somewhere. I don't see lowering our standards is at all a start, it is a step backwards. Just my humble opinion. Judy M. Schermer, CVRT Rehabilitation Services Manager Cincinnati Association for the Blind and Visually Impaired Disclaimer: The information contained in this electronic mail message may be confidential and protected information intended only for the use of the individual or entity named above. As the recipient of this information you may be prohibited by State and Federal law from disclosing this information to any other party without specific written authorization from the individual to whom it pertains. If you have received this communication in error, please notify us immediately and destroy the message and its attachments. ________________________________ From: visionrehabtherapist-bounce@xxxxxxxxxxxxx [mailto:visionrehabtherapist-bounce@xxxxxxxxxxxxx] On Behalf Of Maduffy@xxxxxxx Sent: Wednesday, January 14, 2009 5:38 PM To: visionrehabtherapist@xxxxxxxxxxxxx Subject: [visionrehabtherapist] What do you think about the new ACVREP Certification requiremetns? Dear VRT Colleagues: This is Maureen Duffy, writing to you to express my desire for feedback from my VRT colleagues about the new certification criteria that have been proposed by ACVREP. Let me tell you a little bit about myself and why I am writing. I have been a direct VRT practitioner in New York City, a university graduate program director for 18 years (the VRT Masters and Certificate Programs at PCO, now Salus University), the editorial director of VisionAWARE.org (which has been my vocation for the past two years), and I'm also an Associate Editor of the Journal of Visual Impairment and Blindness (JVIB). Writing is -- and always has been -- my first love, and writing about VRT makes it extra-enjoyable. I've been the Chair of the VRT Division of AER (2000-2002) and I've also just been elected to the Board of Directors of ACVREP, which will be announced very soon. I'm telling you all of this so that you'll understand my commitment to the field, as well as my understanding of all facets of service delivery. Recently, ACVREP released a proposed new set of certification guidelines for VRT, Orientation and Mobility, and Low Vision Therapy. If you go to the ACVREP web site, you can download these new proposed standards in several formats. In essence, ACVREP has proposed two tracks: Full Certification and Provisional Certification. There has been a great uproar from O&M professionals about these proposed guidelines. I have been following these responses on the AER Listserv and most are vehemently NOT in favor of the Provisional Track as it now stands. Yet I have seen very few responses from VRTs -- and this troubles me. What are your thoughts about these new proposed certification standards? Are you in favor? Are you not in favor? Are there provisions you'd like to see changed? I don't want this discussion to be co-opted by O&M professionals. I want our fine profession to state our opinions, too. As a new ACVREP Board member, I want (and need) to hear from you. Again, if you go to the ACVREP web site, you can read the new proposed guidelines. I've also combined several emails that spell out, in great detail, the steps involved in the new proposed Provisional Certification guidelines, and you can read those steps at the end of this email, after my signature line. Please give me your feedback. Please give me your opinions, both good and bad, positive and negative. I want our profession to grow and become stronger. I want us to do this together. Thanks for listening and I look forward to hearing from you. Maureen A. Duffy, CVRT Editorial Director AWARE (Associates for World Action in Rehabilitation & Education) Phone: 914-528-5120 E-mail: maureen.duffy@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Are you aware of our web site? www.visionaware.org <http://www.visionaware.org/> "Self-Help for Vision Loss" __________________________________________________________________ Full Certification The requirements for Track I (Full Certification) are based on the traditional criteria established by ACVREP. To establish eligibility to sit for the applicable certification examination under Full Certification, the candidate must have a Bachelors degree (or higher) in the applicable field of study and successfully completed their supervised internship experience. In recognizing this education and the internship experience, the length of term for Full Certification is five (5) years. In addition, there is no limit for the number of times a Full Certification candidate can sit for the applicable certification exam. Also, those who obtain Full Certification do not have to undergo a review process. Provisional Certification 1. Earn a Bachelor's degree (in any field of study) 2. Obtain a minimum of 60 hours of discipline-specific training / 2000 hours of discipline-specific experience (within five years of submitting the Eligibility Application) and currently provide discipline-specific services. 3. Letter of sponsorship from current employer (to be submitted with the Eligibility Application). ** CLVT Provisional Certification candidates must also submit a letter of sponsorship from a physician and must submit and receive a passing rating on five sample case reports. Rating the of sample case reports is the responsibility of the CLVT Certification Committee (using a rubric). Multiple raters are utilized for inter-rater reliability. 4. Submit Eligibility Application to be reviewed. Any questions or concerns regarding the activities utilized by a Provisional Certification candidate to demonstrate the minimum 60-hour education requirement and/or the 2000 hours of experience are referred to the applicable Certification Committee. The Certification Committee reserves the right to request further information regarding activities utilized to demonstrate these requirements. The committee makes the determination if said activities fulfill the requirements. 5. If the Provisional Certification candidate is found to have met eligibility requirements, they may then sit for the applicable certification examination. If they do not pass the examination within two attempts, they must acquire 10 additional hours of discipline-specific education/training before they may sit for the examination again. 6. If the Provisional Certification candidate passes the applicable exam, he/she will be afforded Provisional Certification (18 month term) based on approval of the full Board. 7. Prior to the conclusion of the Provisional Certification term, the Provisional Certificant must undergo a review process. This review includes the endorsement of the sponsor employer, a performance review (specific form - aligned with the professional competencies) completed by the immediate supervisor, acquire an additional minimum of 10 instructional hours of discipline-specific education/training, and have no reported infractions of the Code of Ethics. ** CLVT Provisional Certificants must also submit a letter of endorsement from the sponsor physician. 8. If the Provisional Certificant is found to have met all review process requirements, he or she will be afforded Full Certification based on approval of the full Board. If a Provisional Certificant is found to have not met the review process requirements, Full Certification is not granted and the individual may only reapply for ACVREP certification under Track I (Full Certification) requiring the individual to obtain a Bachelors degree (or higher) in the applicable field and successfully complete a supervised internship. Provisional Certification Requirements Track II (Provisional Certification Candidates) must meet the following requirements to establish eligibility to sit for the applicable ACVREP certification examination. * Proof of a Bachelor's degree or higher from an accredited college or university (or foreign equivalent, as verified through an independent credential evaluation company) in any field of study; or * (Non-U.S. Trained Candidates Only) Proof of a post-secondary diploma or degree from an accredited college or university. * Proof of a minimum of 60 instructional hours of discipline-specific education/training within five (5) years prior to submitting the ACVREP Vision Rehabilitation Therapist Eligibility Application. * Note: One (1) instructional contact hour is awarded for each hour of learner participation in an organized educational/training activity. * Proof of providing vision rehabilitation therapy services in a professional work setting with a minimum of 2000 hours of vision rehabilitation therapy experience within (5) years prior to submitting the ACVREP Vision Rehabilitation Therapist Eligibility Application. * Sponsorship from current employer to endorse Provisional Certification candidacy and attest good professional standing within the organization. ** CLVT candidates for Provisional Certification are also required have a sponsor physician and must submit five (5) sample case reports and receive a passing score on said case reports prior to sitting for the LVT certification examination. * Provisional Certification candidates must pass the applicable certification examination prior to being afforded Provisional Certification. Furthermore, Provisional Certification candidates are allowed two (2) attempts to pass the applicable certification examination. If a Provisional Certification candidate does not pass the applicable certification examination within two (2) attempts, they are then required to obtain an additional minimum of 10 instructional hours of discipline-specific education/training before they can sit for the certification exam again. * The length of term for Provisional Certification is 18 months. Prior to the completion of the term, the Provisional Certificant must undergo a review process. If the Provisional Certificant is found to have met the requirements set forth in the review process, then he/she will be afforded Full Certification. If the Provisional Certificant is found to have not met the requirements of the review process, then he/she may only reapply for ACVREP certification under Track I (Full Certification). ________________________________ A Good Credit Score is 700 or Above. See yours in just 2 easy steps! <http://pr.atwola.com/promoclk/100000075x1215855013x1201028747/aol?redir =http://www.freecreditreport.com/pm/default.aspx?sc=668072%26hmpgID=62%2 6bcd=DecemailfooterNO62>