I haven't yet read all the replies to this post, so this may have already been said... but I noticed the bird had a habit of opening its wings right before diving, and I never saw any white (assuming this is the same bird that was there a few days ago). Daniel ________________________________ From: Jeff Taylor <birdingtaylor@xxxxxxxxx> To: tn-bird@xxxxxxxxxxxxx Sent: Wednesday, January 4, 2012 6:15 PM Subject: [TN-Bird] Radner Lake Surf or White-winged Scoter?? Received a pic from Jerry Webb today who has birded Radner lake recently and photographed the Scoter. It appears to be a White-winged? Does anyone have any opinions? -JT Jeff Taylor Hendersonville, TN