In a message dated 12/16/2013 12:24:30 P.M. Eastern Standard Time, dryturtles@xxxxxxxxx writes: Stan, I checked out John Schalestock's book publisher and I'm afraid he was scammed. See below article. Scotty Is Tate Publishing a Scam? December 9, 2013 at 10:34 AM I signed with Tate over a year ago and paid the initial investment (close to $4000). 0 The first problems came with the copies of the pre-sale books and promo materials I received for my library visits. The books were full of typos, and my name was misspelled on one entire set of promo materials (pushcards, bookmarks, and postcards to invite family and friends to events). I contacted Tate right away to receive replacement promo materials and never received a full replacement set. As for the typos in the books I requested a PPC process-post production changes, in which the author is charged per correction (presumably because the fault lies in the author, who signs off on the final draft for printing). However, as I began to correct the manuscript I realized the majority of the errors had not been mine to begin with, and the reason I knew this was because many of the errors were present in the foreign terms in my story (part of my novel is set in a foreign country and also has many French ballet terms). In other words, I was having to correct errors made by the editing team at Tate! One example: demi-pointe was changed to semi-point. Accents were removed from most of the foreign words, English words which should have been capitalized (Navy [the military branch], changed to navy) were changed. I went back to my original manuscript, and more than half of the errors had been created during the editing process. So I called my project manager and insisted that they make all the corrections and not charge me; he agreed. So my release date was pushed back about a month, but that was okay by me as long as the retail booksellers got clean, corrected copies. Meanwhile, I had to make multiple contacts to different departments at Tate to prompt them to create my book trailer (which was part of the original contract) and website (which I paid for with my batch of pre-release order); by the way, my website just went online last week, when it should have been up and running last spring to create interest in the upcoming release. Anyway, to make a long story… even longer--I had my first event at my local retail bookseller (which I scheduled-- the bookstore manager told me Tate had not made any contact with them at any time) and sold many copies, but… THE ERRORS ARE STILL IN THERE!! Plus, the book was categorized as an adult romance and must be shelved in that section, alongside bodice-rippers and other risqué titles. MY BOOK IS A YA COMING-OF-AGE STORY!!! It now on the shelf by books with covers of lusty couples and images suggesting BDSM and other crazy stuff. I mean, if you are into that, that's fine; that is not what you will find in my book, and the intended audience will never find my book in the teen section as long as it is categorized as adult romance. Bottom line, if you look at my (and many, many others') experience with Tate and evaluate it by the criteria that Timothy uses, which is "if they say they will do something and then do something else, they are a scam" then TATE PUBLISHING IS OPERATING AS A SCAM! They don't edit their manuscripts properly, they don't market and publicize their titles, they don't distribute to retail outlets (my local bookstore only ordered copies because I set up the event), they don't produce effective professional-looking book trailers or promo materials, they don't send publicity info to the media, and they don't broadcast their book trailers on national t.v. I am now convinced that they make our books available to distributors but do not exert any effort in actually getting them into bookstore and other retail outlets to keep sales down and avoid having to refund our investments. I am not going to blame them if I don't become a NY Times best-selling author, but I do blame them for not honoring their contract and exercising shady sales practices.