[ SHOWGSD-L ] Ohio Dog Bill Hearings
- From: Crossroadsgsd@xxxxxxx
- To: showgsd-l@xxxxxxxxxxxxx
- Date: Thu, 8 May 2008 23:26:07 EDT
Hearings This Week On Proposed
Ohio Dog And Kennel Legislation
Please Contact Your Legislators And Senators
by JOHN YATES
American Sporting Dog Alliance
_http://www.americansportingdogalliance.org_
(http://www.americansportingdogalliance.org/)
COLUMBUS, OH â?? Hearings are scheduled for Tuesday and Thursday on two pieces
of legislation that would have a severe impact on all dog owners and hobby
breeders in Ohio.
The Senate State and Local Government and Veteransâ?? Affairs Committee will
receive a reported substitute bill for S.B. 173 (House version is H.B. 223) on
Tuesday at 10 a.m. in the South Hearing Room. Testimony will not be taken on
this new bill. This legislation imposes heavy financial and legal burdens on
kennel owners.
On Thursday, at 8:30 a.m. in the Finance Hearing Room, a hearing will be
held to review reported amendments to H.B. 446, which affects all dog owners.
The House Local Municipal Government and Urban Revitalization Committee
reportedly will take testimony at this hearing. The reported amendments were
not
made available to the public by Monday morning.
It appears that an attempt is being made to ram these two bills through the
legislative process as quickly as possible.
These two bills take a giant step toward fulfilling the extreme animal
rights agenda of the eventual elimination of the private ownership of animals.
They would drastically reduce the number of puppies available in Ohio by
sharply
curtailing hobby breeding of purebred dogs.
A Senate fiscal analysis of S.S. 173 shows that additional licensing costs
will exceed $300,000 for an estimated 2,000 kennels that would be classified
as small hobby breeding kennels.
Under the legislation, a small breeding kennel is defined as having between
nine and 15 dogs, which would impact most hobby kennels.
In addition, the analysis shows, a new supervisory position would cost about
$60,000, and an unspecified number of dog wardens would have to be hired at
$43,000 each. Estimates of the number of new dog wardens needed to enforce
the law range from a minimum of 17 ($700,000 a year) to 88 ($3.8 million a
year), plus numerous start-up costs.
These and other expenses would come out of the pockets of kennel owners.
Our prior reports have contained detailed analysis of this legislation, and
this report will only summarize. For readers who want an in-depth analysis,
please contact us at _asda@xxxxxxxxxxxxx (mailto:asda@xxxxxxxxxxxx) .
S.B. 173 (companion to H.B. 223) has the potential to destroy hobby breeding
of purebred dogs in Ohio in a misdirected effort to curtail â??puppy mills.â??
H.B. 446 mandates licensing for puppies at eight weeks of age, increases
fees, reduces the age for a spay/neuter differential to six months, gives
county
auditors the power to revoke kennel licenses, and makes it much harder for
good Samaritans to help lost dogs.
Testimony on the bills has been mixed, with only a few people attending
previous hearings. However, some of the legislators and senators asked some
hard
questions and expressed doubts. Others, however, have signed on as cosponsors
to this legislation.
The American Sporting Dog Alliance is supporting Ohio dog and kennel owners
in an effort to defeat this legislation, and has offered strong testimony in
opposition to the two bills. Ohio Valley Dog Owners President Norma Bennett
Woolf has addressed the hearings on behalf of dog owners. Ms. Woolf has worked
tirelessly to defeat this destructive legislation, and she is one of the
true heroes of the movement to protect dog ownersâ?? rights.
We strongly urge all Ohio dog and kennel owners to take an active role. Your
participation and support are crucial. We cannot emphasize too strongly that
this legislation stems from an extreme animal rights agenda that aims to
greatly reduce the number of dogs as a giant step toward eliminating dog
ownership altogether.
S.B. 173
This legislation (a companion to H.B. 223) claims to target â??puppy mills,â??
but would have a devastating impact on every kennel that has nine or more
unsterilized adult dogs that could be construed as a â??breeding dog.â??
Because of
the definition and required burden of proof, almost all small hobby breeders
will be affected.
A breeding dog is defined as any male or female dog that is intended for
breeding or has produced one litter in a year, either as a stud dog or a
mother.
The law does not define standards for this definition or for the burden of
proof, and the burden of proof rests with the kennel owner. We see this as a
â??
Catch 22,â?? as there would be no way to conclusively prove the purpose for
keeping any dog. It would a matter of convincing the dog warden to take the
owner
â??s word.
This unvarnished animal rights legislation also grants dog wardens the power
to confiscate any dog for which there is probable cause to call a breeding
dog. The standards for probable cause are not defined, but could be construed
as any dog that has the potential for being bred.
To obtain a breeding license, a kennel owner would have to pay an annual fee
ranging from $150 to $750, submit to inspections by state officials, provide
proof of insurance, purchase a bond guaranteeing financial liability, submit
to a personal background check by the police, be fingerprinted and obtain
and use an approved vendor number to advertise or sell a dog or puppy.
Inspections would open any area that houses dogs to state officials without
a warrant, including the ownerâ??s home. Papers, documents and bank records
also could be examined or subpoenaed.
Citations can be given and fines levied for violations or â??threatened
violations,â?? which are not defined. Any hearing, trial or appeal of an
action must
be done through only one Ohio court, in Franklin County.
The inspections would be based on providing a specified level of physical
care in housing, sanitation, medical care and food and water.
They would require a kennel to be cleaned every 12 hours, mandate
professional veterinary care for even minor conditions, injuries or ailments,
require
grooming and nail trimming, mandate vaccinations, deworming and heartworm
prevention, and require available water at all times, even in freezing
weather.
Here is a link to the actual text of this legislation:
_http://www.legislature.state.oh.us/bills.cfm?ID=127_SB_173_
(http://www.legislature.state.oh.us/bills.cfm?ID=127_SB_173) .
We urge dog and kennel owners to submit written comments to each member of
the committee. Emails, letters and phone calls all are important. This is
urgent!
This link will take you to a list of the committee members:
_http://www.senate.state.oh.us/committees/com_state.html_
(http://www.senate.state.oh.us/committees/com_state.html) . A page will open
up giving you a link to each senator
â??s email and mailing addresses.
HB 446
Every dog owner will be affected by HB 446.
It says:
* Puppies must be licensed for $10 apiece at eight weeks of age, and
also must wear a collar and license tag at that age. A puppy must be
registered and licensed before it can be sold or transferred. Unlicensed
puppies and
dogs can be confiscated.
* Individual dog licenses would rise from $2 to $10 per year, and
kennel license costs would rise from $10 to $50. The extra charge for
licensing
for a dog that is not spayed or neutered will be imposed on dogs at six months
of age, instead of the current nine months
* Kennel licenses would be required for anyone who raises a single
litter of hunting dogs. The bill says: â??A kennel owner is a person,
partnership,
firm, company, or corporation professionally engaged in the business of
breeding dogs for hunting or for sale.â??
* A particularly onerous part of the legislation gives county auditors
the unrestricted power to revoke kennel licenses (this includes anyone who
raises a single litter of hunting dogs) for unproven allegations of animal
cruelty. County auditors do not have the qualifications to make judgments
about
animal cruelty, and the guilt or innocence of a dog owner facing such
accusations should be determined only in a court of law. This power is given
to
auditors â??if the auditor determinesâ?? that a violation of animal cruelty
statutes
has occurred. No limits are placed on this power, and the legislation does
not define any criteria for an auditor to use. In fact, the law gives an
auditor the power to revoke a license if he/she simply feels that a kennel
owner
may have violated cruelty statutes, or even extra-legal personal opinions
about what constitutes cruelty.
* Good Samaritans who find a stray dog must notify authorities within
two days and turn it over to the animal control agency within 10 days, and do
not have the option to give the dog to a no-kill shelter or rescue group, or
find someone to take the dog if its owner cannot be found. This exposes the
dog to a high probability of euthanasia.
Other provisions regulate dogs that are declared dangerous, cats, ferrets
and other animals.
The purpose of greatly increased fees is to make law-abiding dog owners pay
for the cost of animal control in Ohio. The unfairness and irrationality of
this approach is that responsible dog owners and breeders, who are perhaps the
least likely cause of the problem, are the people who are being forced to
pay for it.
Breeders and owners of purebred dogs rarely burden animal control agencies
and animal shelters. Moreover, purebred puppies almost never are found in
municipal animal shelters. This legislation makes responsible dog owners and
breeders the â??cash cowâ?? that will be milked to pay for animal control
efforts
directed at irresponsible people who ignore the law. ASDA regards this as the
unethical exploitation of law-abiding citizens.
People who actually violate the law should pay for the cost of enforcing it,
through fines and other penalties. This cost should not be borne by
law-abiding dog owners. We should not be held responsible for the actions of
others,
over which we have no control.
We urge dog and kennel owners to submit written comments to each member of
the committee.
Here is a link to the text of the legislation:
_http://www.legislature.state.oh.us/bills.cfm?ID=127_HB_446_
(http://www.legislature.state.oh.us/bills.cfm?ID=127_HB_446) .
This link will take you to a list of the committee members:
_http://www.house.state.oh.us/jsps/Committee.jsp?ID=21_
(http://www.house.state.oh.us/jsps/Committee.jsp?ID=21) . Please click on each
memberâ??s name. A page will open up
giving you a link to the legislatorâ??s email and mailing addresses.
Please feel free to use any information contained in this report, and also
to cross-post it and forward it to your friends.
The American Sporting Dog Alliance is the unified voice of sporting dog
owners and professionals in America. We work at the grassroots level to defeat
unfair legislation and policies that are harmful to dogs and the people who
own
and work with them. Our work to protect your rights is supported solely by
the donations of our members. Your participation and membership are vital to
our success. Please visit us on the web at
_http://www.americansportingdogalliance.org_
(http://www.americansportingdogalliance.org/) .
Have You Joined Yet?
The American Sporting Dog Alliance
_http://www.americansportingdogalliance.org_
(http://www.americansportingdogalliance.org/)
Cathleen Bennett & Joe Guay
Rialto, Ca
_www.crossroadsgsd.com_ (http://www.crossroadsgsd.com/)
Raised with LOVE, Sold with Care
Updated Web site
Puppies Here
**************Wondering what's for Dinner Tonight? Get new twists on family
favorites at AOL Food.
(http://food.aol.com/dinner-tonight?NCID=aolfod00030000000001)
============================================================================
POST is Copyrighted 2007. All material remains the property of the original
author and of GSD Communication, Inc. NO REPRODUCTIONS or FORWARDS of any kind
are permitted without prior permission of the original author AND of the
Showgsd-l Management. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
ALL PERSONS ARE ON NOTICE THAT THE FORWARDING, REPRODUCTION OR USE IN ANY
MANNER OF ANY MATERIAL WHICH APPEARS ON SHOWGSD-L WITHOUT THE EXPRESS
PERMISSION OF ALL PARTIES TO THE POST AND THE LIST MANAGEMENT IS EXPRESSLY
FORBIDDEN, AND IS A VIOLATION OF LAW. VIOLATORS OF THIS PROHIBITION WILL BE
PROSECUTED.
For assistance, please contact the List Management at admin@xxxxxxxxxxxx
VISIT OUR WEBSITE - www.showgsd.org
============================================================================
Other related posts:
- » [ SHOWGSD-L ] Ohio Dog Bill Hearings
