A good pump like that would also be as much as many print washers I could buy. Now to address the durability is another question. Im not going to just leave it running 24 hours a day. It will be on a few hours at a time, worst case senerio several times a week. I don't get to play in my darkroom every day. I also plan on draining after each session. The other thing is that the pump unlike may in its intended use is likely to be used at a flow rate that is well under what it is likely capable of doing. That also will keep the stress on the pump to a minimum. Fish tank pumps are indeed designed to move water 24hours a day, and so are pumps for fountains and ponds. Now will they take the demands?? That remains to be seen, but as I learned with the sink you can overbuild just as easy as underbuild. The acid or possiblity of it should be something I can deal with potentially by running a solution of water and baking soda through it, then rinsing if the concentration levels get up. Its something I wouldn't have thought of had you not said anything Frank. Whether I agree or not is really not important. The discussion is making me think. If the only way to make this workis a $200 pump, then the project goes no further. There are other ways to go other than that. Frank Filippone <red735i@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote: A good pump, as I suggested, will cost $100-150. It will last probably a few dozen years. A cheap Home Depot sump pump will cost maybe $50 and die in a year ( acid or not, sump pumps are not made for running 100% of the time, except for short intervals)....... Jim, it is his choice. Is it a valid choice? Yes, is it a prudent choice, you and I would say not. Little Giant Pump Company....... http://www.lgpc.com/MagDrive/ByCategory.aspx?TypeID=4&CategoryID=17 This one looks about right......, depending on flow rates.... Item Number: 589002 Frank Filippone red735i@xxxxxxxxxxxxx You know the old saying: Buy cheap, buy twice! The problem with something breaking, or wearing out, is that it ALWAYS happens at the most inopportune time possible. I have long given-up on buying cheap, whenever possible. Jim At 10:33 AM 3/8/2007 -0800, Frank Filippone wrote: >Good points... I agree. Several cheap pumps >may cost less than 1 more expensive one. > >Frank Filippone >red735i@xxxxxxxxxxxxx >Replacing a cheap pump every few years is >probably going to happen anyway from mechanical >or other factors like potentially just wearing out. > > ============================================================================================================= To unsubscribe from this list, go to www.freelists.org and logon to your account (the same e-mail address and password you set-up when you subscribed,) and unsubscribe from there. --------------------------------- Need Mail bonding? Go to the Yahoo! Mail Q&A for great tips from Yahoo! Answers users.