I have not seen them myself, but have heard of Barn Swallow nests in caves in central Oregon and Lava Beds National Monument (N CA). "Birds of Oregon: A General Reference" doesn't have as much detail as I would like regarding Oregon examples; just says there are/were some. If anyone in oboland has personal experience with a Barn Swallow nest on something other than a human-built structure in Oregon, I would be interested to hear about it. Matt Hunter Melrose, OR On Tue, Aug 6, 2013 at 12:48 PM, Paul T. Sullivan < paultsullivan@xxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote: > Matt, > > So we have BARN OWLS and BARN SWALLOWS (not to mention Chimney Swifts and > House Sparrows). What did these species use in the first million years of > their existence before humans built the structures that became part of our > name for these birds? > > Clearly Barn Owls used cavities in hollow trees and cliffs. Swifts used > hollow trees. The sparrows are weaver-finches that can build big messy > nests in trees. > > But what is the "natural" nest site for a Barn Swallow? Where would they > be without porch overhangs, garden sheds, barns eves, and bridges? Good > question. Kenn Kaufmann (Lives of North American Birds, 1996) says they > used cliffs or shallow caves. I'm not sure I've ever seen a Barn Swallow in > a "natural" nest site. > > Cheers, > > Paul > > ================= > Subject: Re: Cliff-nesting Cliff Swallows > Date: Tue Aug 6 2013 13:21 pm > From: matthewghunter AT gmail.com > > Thanks for the note Marcia. Vague memories are sometimes the source of > interesting observations, so I appreciate you throwing it out there/here. > > The most likely candidate for swallows nesting on/in a hill/cliffside along > a road in most of western Oregon is actually the Violet-green Swallow. ... > > Regarding Barn Swallows, I have never heard of a > "natural" nest site for Barn Swallow in western Oregon. Anyone else? > > Thanks, > > Matt Hunter > Melrose, OR >