Jackie, The pattern on the forewing clearly makes this a Catocala. I can't tell the size and obviously cannot see the underwing pattern but it looks similar to 8878.1 C. lineella (Little Lined Underwing), an oak feeder that flies in July-Aug and occurs in our area. Merrill J. Merrill Lynch Echo Valley Farm Watauga County, NC 3,400 feet elevation Sent from my iPad On Nov 30, 2011, at 8:22 PM, Jackie Nelson <ephemeropterae@xxxxxxxxx> wrote: > Going nowhere with this ID. Photo is from 7/28, S. Appalachians, North > Carolina. > This is one of those you think will be easy to ID but you never see the exact > one. I don't even know where to start, although I'm on my 2nd pass through > the plates for my unidentifieds. > > Any help appreciated! > > Jackie > > > > <IMG_7979.JPG>