[lit-ideas] in-class censorship
- From: JulieReneB@xxxxxxx
- To: lit-ideas@xxxxxxxxxxxxx
- Date: Wed, 31 Mar 2004 17:15:54 EST
I want to know what people here think about this. My 4th grade daughter came
home today and told me that her teacher is reading "Belle Teal"l, by Ann
Martin to them. I haven't read it, but my older daughter owns the book and has
read it. Elena told me that when her teacher was reading aloud today, she came
to a place where she said "and then she called her a bad word three times".
Elena then said, "But I know what that bad word was because I saw it in my
friend's book cuz she had it open."
The passage reads:
<<Clarice looks uncertain. So I step in. 'Only if you want to fight a
girl,' I tell him.
Now Vernon looks uncertain. He drops his fists, but he says, 'Okay.
Niggerloversniggerloversniggerlovers.'
'My father --' Claric starts to say, but her face just crumples.
I am feeling all cool and calm. 'Vernon,' I say. And then I add, 'Chas,'
since Chas is hovering behind him. 'Clarice and me are friends with Darryl and
you better get used to it.'
'Your *friend*,' replies Vernon, 'doesn't belong in *our* school.'>>
Aside from the fact that language on prime time broadcast tv crossed all
kinds of lines long ago, and my child hears every 4 letter word there is on the
school bus, I'm a little surprised at this spontaneous censorship of the text
on the part of the teacher. What do you guys think? Is it appropriate? Is it
something you would expect, or that is customary? Does that particular
phrase warrent editing out? If a book contains words a teacher does not deem
appropriate for an age group, should the age group be reading the book?
Doesn't
editing that out w/out even explaining what the epithet was or meant rob the
text of some of the power it should have for the young readers, part of what
one
would hope they would learn from it and the very reason it was possibly
chosen? I was suprised and had an instinctively negative reaction, but need to
think more about why.
Julie Krueger
------------------------------------------------------------------
To change your Lit-Ideas settings (subscribe/unsub, vacation on/off,
digest on/off), visit www.andreas.com/faq-lit-ideas.html
Other related posts:
