Anyone who is a philosopher _knows_ that the title +> (conversationally implicates) S. E. Toulmin is dead. Indeed, the author of "The Uses of Inference" passed recently. I would be interested to know the origin of "Toulmin" qua name. Sounds Anglo-Saxon to me but perhaps it's Welsh? Anyway, The Uses of Inference was predated by a series of articles he published. Someone should publish his whole bibliography. Toulmin was, perhaps for a weekend or two, associated with Oxford, but he was on the main a light-blue philosopher. May he rest in peace, where 'he' is cataphoric. Cheers, JL Speranza Buenos Aires, Argentina