https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2019/jan/11/hitachi-cancel-plans-nuclear-power-station-angelsey-wales
[links in online article]
Hitachi set to cancel plans for £16bn nuclear power station in Wales
Move by Japanese firm would be blow to UK plans to replace coal plants
and ageing reactors
Adam Vaughan
Fri 11 Jan 2019 13.48 GMT
Last modified on Fri 11 Jan 2019 23.35 GMT
The Japanese conglomerate Hitachi looks certain to cancel its plans for
a £16bn nuclear power station in Wales, leaving Britain’s ambitions for
a nuclear renaissance in tatters.
An impasse in months-long talks between the company, London and Toyko on
financing is expected to result in the flagship project being axed at a
Hitachi board meeting next week, according to the Nikkei newspaper.
The company has spent nearly £2bn on the planned Wylfa power station on
Anglesey, which would have powered around 5m homes.
Another Japanese giant, Toshiba, scrapped a nuclear plant in Cumbria
just two months ago after failing to find a buyer for the ailing project.
Withdrawal by Hitachi would be a major blow to the UK’s plans to replace
dirty coal and ageing reactors with new nuclear power plants, and heap
pressure on ministers to consider other large-scale alternatives such as
offshore windfarms.
It would also mark an end to Japan’s hopes of exporting its nuclear
technology around the world.
Hitachi and the UK and Japanese governments have been negotiating over a
guaranteed price of power from Wylfa and a potentially £5bn-plus UK
public stake in the scheme.
Talks have proved “tricky to find a solution that works for all
parties”, industry sources said.
Unions said the prospect of Wylfa being cancelled was extremely worrying
and losing two projects in such a short period “should set alarm bells
ringing” about the government’s commitment to nuclear.
Hitachi said it had made no final decision. “No formal decision has been
made in this regard currently, while Hitachi has been assessing the
Horizon Project including its potential suspension and related financial
impacts in terms of economic rationality as a private company,” it said.
The reference to a “potential suspension”, however, was the first
official public confirmation that a withdrawal was being considered.
Advertisement
Horizon Nuclear Power, the UK subsidiary behind the scheme, said it
“won’t be commenting on rumours or speculation”.
However, an insider said: “There has been a serious rift in Hitachi, and
the group that said this is too large and risky an investment of
Japanese capital have won out. They pointed to the uncertainty created
by Brexit to say this was another reason to pull the plug.”
The Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy said:
“Negotiations with Hitachi on agreeing a deal that provides value for
money for consumers and taxpayers on the Wylfa project are ongoing.”
It is believed that the deadlock in the negotiations has been due
primarily to the Japanese government being unwilling to provide the
finance to make the numbers work. Hitachi and the UK government by
comparison “had gone a long way”.
The Japanese prime minister, Shinzō Abe, insisted that the fate of the
nuclear plant had not been discussed during his talks with Theresa May
on Thursday, even though they spent more than three hours together in
two separate sessions.
Hitachi would face a significant but not fatal financial hit from
writing off the Wylfa scheme. It has spent nearly £2bn on the power
station, including £700m on buying the project from the German utilities
E.ON and RWE in 2012.
Rebecca Long-Bailey, the shadow business secretary, said the prospect of
Wylfa being cancelled was very worrying for the economy and jobs in
north Wales and could have “a significant negative impact on the UK’s
energy security, particularly after the collapse of the Moorside power
station plans in 2018.”
She added: “The prime minister must tell the public if she discussed
Hitachi’s plans for Wylfa with Shinzō Abe during his visit this week.”
Sue Ferns, the Prospect union’s senior deputy general secretary, said:
“New nuclear is of significant strategic importance for the country. The
government must not sleepwalk into an energy security crisis by allowing
these projects to fail one by one.”
The Welsh government said it was pressing Whitehall to make the project
work. “This is a major project with potentially significant economic
benefits to Anglesey, north Wales and Wales,” a spokesperson said.
Advertisement
Nuclear critics said a collapse of the scheme was not a disaster but an
opportunity for a policy shift. Doug Parr, the chief scientist of
Greenpeace UK, said: “We could have locked ourselves into reliance on an
obsolete, unaffordable technology, but we’ve been given the chance to
think again and make a better decision.”
Sara Medi Jones, the acting secretary general of CND, said: “With
offshore wind now cheaper than nuclear it’s clear there is a clean and
workable alternative. We just need the political will to make it happen.”
Just one new nuclear power station, EDF Energy’s Hinkley Point C in
Somerset, has been given the green light and begun construction. The
French company and Chinese firm CGN both want to build more.
